Check out this answer from Consensus:
Current research indicates that mouth taping may not significantly improve asthma control, although it could affect physiological parameters such as ETCO2 levels. While generally considered safe for most individuals, it is crucial to approach mouth taping with caution, particularly for those with underlying respiratory issues. Further research is needed to fully understand the benefits and risks associated with this practice.
Mouth taping, a practice where individuals tape their mouths shut during sleep to encourage nasal breathing, has gained attention for its potential health benefits. However, concerns about its safety and effectiveness remain. This article explores the current research on mouth taping, particularly its impact on asthma control and physiological effects.
The Concept of Mouth Taping
Mouth taping is often recommended by practitioners of the Buteyko technique, a method that emphasizes nasal breathing to improve respiratory health. The rationale behind this practice is that nasal breathing filters, warms, and humidifies the air, which can be beneficial for individuals with respiratory conditions such as asthma.
Research on Mouth Taping and Asthma Control
Study 1: Effect on Asthma Control
A randomized, single-blind crossover study investigated the impact of mouth taping on asthma control in patients with symptomatic asthma. The study involved 51 participants who alternated between periods of usual breathing and mouth taping at night. The primary outcomes measured were morning peak expiratory flow and symptom scores1.
Findings:
- No significant differences were observed in morning peak expiratory flow or symptom scores between the mouth taping and usual breathing periods.
- The majority of participants found mouth taping to be acceptable, but it did not improve asthma control.
Conclusion: Mouth taping at night did not enhance asthma control in patients with symptomatic asthma, suggesting that it may not be an effective intervention for this purpose1.
Study 2: Effects on End-Tidal Carbon Dioxide Levels
A pilot study examined the physiological effects of mouth taping, specifically its impact on end-tidal carbon dioxide (ETCO2) levels. The study included nine participants with mild stable asthma who underwent both oral and nasal breathing conditions2.
Findings:
- ETCO2 levels increased during both oral and nasal breathing, with a slightly higher increase during nasal breathing.
- The increase in ETCO2 was more pronounced in individuals who were natural oral breathers.
Conclusion: Mouth taping may lead to an increase in ETCO2 levels, particularly in those who typically breathe through their mouths. This finding suggests that nasal breathing encouraged by mouth taping could have physiological effects that warrant further investigation2.
Safety Concerns and Considerations
While the studies reviewed did not report significant adverse effects from mouth taping, it is essential to consider potential risks. These may include:
- Breathing Difficulties: Individuals with nasal obstructions or sleep apnea may experience difficulty breathing if their mouths are taped shut.
- Discomfort: Some individuals may find the sensation of having their mouths taped uncomfortable or anxiety-inducing.