Was the Roman Gladiator an Athlete?

doi:10.1080/00948705.2006.9714689

Was the Roman Gladiator an Athlete?

Published May 1, 2006 · H. Reid

Journal of the Philosophy of Sport

Q2 SJR score

9

Citations

1

Influential Citations

Full text

Semantic Scholar

Abstract

Historians traditionally exclude Roman gladiators from their books on ancient sport. They classify their munera as shows or spectacles, and they relegate gladiators to the category of servants or entertainers. The term “athlete” is usually reserved for contestants in Olympic-style agones, and the shining ideal of Classical Greek athletics consigns the events of the Roman arena to darkness. After pointing out in Athletics in the Ancient World that Hellenic contests exist for the sake of the competitors, who are free citizens, Gardiner sniffs, “The Roman games are ludi, amusements, entertainments, and the performers are slaves or hirelings; they exist for the spectators” (10: p. 119). Is this exclusion justifi ed? Few modern athletes have a problem with being “hirelings”; some actually cultivate their status as entertainers. Today, philosophers of sport tend to be more open about what counts as sport and who can be called an athlete. Even those who deny, for example, that so-called professional wrestling is a sport may still be willing to call its participants athletes. Nevertheless, there is something signifi cant about the distinction between Romeʼs gritty gladiators and Greeceʼs idealized Olympians. It is a distinction based on the Hellenic association of athletics with virtue and the background assumptions about sport made by those who still buy into that association. It is signifi cant because the ancient Greek use of athletics as character education serves as a foundation and defense of sport in education today. Romans generally rejected athletics as part of education for the upper classes (18: p. 258), so those looking at sport to cultivate virtue today will understandably adopt Greek and reject Roman models of sport. Furthermore, their reasons for doing so will revolve around moral principles such as meritocracy, responsibility, and respect for persons. Is the rejection of gladiators and their munera justifi ed according to these criteria? The ancient Olympics were open only to free men and boys of Greek descent who swore an oath not to sin against the games; victory was viewed as a confi rmation of aristocracy. Greek gymnasia were usually publicly funded educational centers, and athletic training was thought to cultivate and reveal the physical and moral virtues that made worthy citizens. Gladiators, in contrast, occupied the class of moral outcasts called infamia, and they were apparently forced to kill for entertainment. But do these historical facts about athlete exploitation, forced participation, and the constant threat of death amount to a cogent argument against munera being sport? And even if they show that munera fail, when compared with Olympic-style sport, to respect the dignity and autonomy of their contestants, does it follow that gladiators should not be considered athletes as capable of virtue as their Greek counterparts?

Study Snapshot

Key takeawayRoman gladiators are often considered entertainers rather than athletes, but their role in entertainment and their association with virtue may not justify their exclusion from ancient sport history.

PopulationOlder adults (50-71 years)

Sample size24

MethodsObservational

OutcomesBody Mass Index projections

ResultsSocial networks mitigate obesity in older groups.

Was the Roman Gladiator an Athlete?

References

Seneca, Letters from a Stoic: Epistulae Morales ad Lucilium

Seneca's Stoic philosophy, promoting self-possession and virtuous living, helped ease the transition to Christianity in ancient Rome.

Ancient Greek Athletics

Commercialization of book publishing in late imperial China expanded cultural production and challenged the imperial monopoly over literature and orthodox culture, benefiting literati-merchants-businessmen and challenging the state's control over cultural orthodoxy.

Sport in the ancient world from A to Z

This dictionary-format volume provides a comprehensive overview of Greek and Roman sports, with useful links to key sources and a timeline of significant events.

Fair Play in Sport: A Moral Norm System

Fair play in sport competitions can be achieved through a moral norm system, based on rational morality and a utilitarian calculus.

Emperors and Gladiators

Gladiators played a significant role in Roman identity, and their status and status influenced imperial and popular sovereignty.

Fair Play: Sports, Values, And Society

Fair Play in sports is a complex issue, involving ethics, equality, and social values, with implications for intercollegiate athletics and their role in society.

Citations

MMA and the purist/partisan distinction

MMA's status as an individual combat sport mitigates the partisanship often seen in team sports, and external attitudes like betting and purist attitudes also shape spectatorship.

Koshti/Wrestling: A Victory Key for Heroes in Shahnameh

Wrestling, a key strategy in Shahnameh, determines the ultimate winner of battles, promoting heroic values and improving the philosophy, moral atmosphere, and behavior of modern sports.

Sports, entertainment, and the Classical world: Their usefulness to modern sports policy

Ancient sports positions on cheating and doping may provide insights for modern anti-doping policies.

Athletes as heroes and role models: an ancient model

Ancient athletes were not heroes, but rather part of a cultural conspiracy to celebrate and inspire virtue by connecting communities to their heroic past.

Philosophy of Sport: Core Readings

This book offers insights into human movement and physical activity, providing inspiration for a better life through both theoretical and practical applications.

The Spectacle of Bloodshed in Roman Society

Spectacles of bloodshed in ancient Rome were popular entertainment, serving as punishments, promoting interactions between rulers and citizens, and providing meals for citizens.

Cloud of Suspicion: Investigating the Effects of Clouds of Suspicion on Sports Heroes' Perceived Endorsement Values

A cloud of suspicion regarding steroid use in professional and Olympic sports can negatively impact a sports hero's perceived endorsement value, affecting their income from endorsement deals.

Sport, Games, Women and Warriors: An Historical and Philosophical Examination of the

The early Irish Ulster Cycle of tales reveals the importance of sport-like activity in the ancient world, defining warrior status and promoting martial education, with women playing a key role in warrior training.