Best sleep aid
Pro Research Analysisby 
Searched over 200M research papers
Best Sleep Aid: A Comprehensive Review
Introduction to Sleep Aids
Sleep aids are commonly used to address sleep-related issues such as insomnia and sleep disturbances. These aids can be categorized into prescription medications, over-the-counter (OTC) drugs, natural products, and non-pharmacological methods. This article synthesizes recent research to identify the most effective sleep aids.
Prescription Sleep Aids
Prescription sleep aids, including sedative-hypnotics and certain antidepressants, are often used to treat severe insomnia. However, their use is limited due to potential side effects and the risk of dependency. For instance, a study on sleep aid use during breast cancer adjuvant chemotherapy found that prescription sedative/hypnotics were frequently used, but highlighted the need for careful monitoring due to potential side effects3.
Over-the-Counter Sleep Aids
OTC sleep aids, such as those containing diphenhydramine or doxylamine, are widely used but not well-studied. Research indicates that these aids are often used inappropriately, especially among older adults, leading to risks such as daytime sedation and cognitive impairment7. Another study found that OTC sleep aids are more commonly used than benzodiazepines among university students, though the potential side effects and long-term efficacy remain under-researched5.
Natural Sleep Aids
Natural products derived from single plants, such as valerian, are popular for their perceived safety. However, systematic reviews have shown that the evidence supporting their efficacy is inconclusive. Valerian, despite being the most studied, has not consistently demonstrated significant benefits over placebos in improving sleep quality2 8. This suggests a need for more rigorous studies to validate the effectiveness of these natural products.
Non-Pharmacological Sleep Aids
Music as a Sleep Aid
Music is another non-pharmacological method that has been explored for its sleep-inducing properties. A study analyzing the features of music that aid sleep found that pieces with middle-range frequencies, medium tempo, legato articulation, and major mode were most effective4. This indicates that not all sedative music is conducive to sleep, and specific musical characteristics play a crucial role.
White Noise
White noise is often used to mask disruptive sounds and improve sleep quality. However, a systematic review revealed mixed results, with some studies showing improvements in sleep onset and quality, while others indicated potential disruptions9. The variability in findings suggests that more research is needed to establish the efficacy and safety of white noise as a sleep aid.
Novel Sleep Aid Devices
Innovative devices, such as those using air-CO2 mixed gas, have shown promise in reducing sleep latency and improving overall sleep quality. Clinical trials demonstrated significant improvements in sleep metrics without adverse health effects, suggesting a new avenue for treating sleep disorders6.
Conclusion
The effectiveness of sleep aids varies widely across different types. Prescription medications and OTC drugs are commonly used but come with potential risks and side effects. Natural products like valerian lack consistent evidence of efficacy, while non-pharmacological methods such as music and white noise show promise but require further validation. Novel devices using air-CO2 mixtures offer a new, potentially effective approach. Future research should focus on long-term efficacy and safety to provide clearer guidance on the best sleep aids.
Sources and full results
Most relevant research papers on this topic
Use of sleep aids during the first year of life.
Infants during the first year of life use various sleep aids frequently and interchangeably, rather than focusing on a specific favorite object.
Non-RCTNatural Products from Single Plants as Sleep Aids: A Systematic Review.
Single plant-derived natural products show limited evidence with inconclusive results on their effects on sleep, warranting further studies.
Systematic ReviewSleep aid use during and following breast cancer adjuvant chemotherapy
During and after breast cancer adjuvant chemotherapy, women often use various sleep aids, including prescription sedatives, antidepressants, and over-the-counter analgesics.
RCTMusical features that aid sleep
Music that aids sleep has middle range frequencies, medium tempo, legato articulation, major mode, and lyrics, but not necessarily sedative music.
Observational StudyOver-the-counter sleep aids: Widely used but rarely studied
Over-the-counter sleep aids are widely used for sleep problems, but alcohol is used more frequently by men than women, with potential side effects and tolerance effects.
Literature ReviewA novel sleep aid device to reduce sleep latency using air–CO2 mixed gas
The developed device effectively reduces sleep latency and enhances overall sleep quality by spraying a mixed gas of carbon dioxide and air, without adversely affecting human health.
Sleep Health and Appropriate Use of OTC Sleep Aids in Older Adults—Recommendations of a Gerontological Society of America Workgroup
Older adults are more likely to use OTC sleep aids inappropriately, posing risks like daytime sedation and cognitive decline.
Rigorous JournalA systematic review of valerian as a sleep aid: safe but not effective.
Valerian is a safe herb with rare adverse events, but its clinical efficacy as a sleep aid for insomnia remains inconclusive.
Systematic Review
Highly CitedNoise as a sleep aid: A systematic review.
Continuous white noise has low quality evidence for improving sleep, contradicting its widespread use.
Systematic ReviewPatterns of Concomitant Prescription, Over-the-Counter and Natural Sleep Aid Use over a 12-Month Period: A Population Based Study.
Patterns of sleep aid use can help identify individuals vulnerable to inappropriate self-medicating practices, potentially reducing healthcare consultations and improving sleep quality.
Observational Study
Very Rigorous Journal