Do brain games make you smarter?
Pro Research Analysisby
Searched over 200M research papers
Consensus Meter
Do Brain Games Make You Smarter?
Introduction to Brain Games and Cognitive Enhancement
Brain games, often marketed as tools to enhance cognitive functions, have gained popularity in recent years. These games claim to improve various mental abilities such as memory, attention, and problem-solving skills. However, the scientific community remains divided on whether these games truly make individuals smarter or if their benefits are limited to the tasks practiced within the games.
Impact of Action Video Games on Cognitive Skills
Research has shown that action video games can have a positive impact on certain cognitive skills. A meta-analysis covering studies from 2000 to 2015 found that habitual action video game players exhibited enhanced top-down attention and spatial cognition. Long-term intervention studies also indicated that playing action video games could induce changes in cognition, although the effects were smaller compared to cross-sectional studies. These findings suggest that while action video games can improve specific cognitive domains, the overall impact on general intelligence remains modest.
Limited Transfer of Training in Casual Video Games
Studies on casual video games have shown mixed results regarding their ability to enhance cognitive functions. One study involving 209 young adults found that while participants improved on the training games, the transfer to untrained tasks was limited. Specifically, no significant gains were observed in reasoning, working memory, episodic memory, or perceptual speed. However, improvements were noted in divided attention tasks, particularly for those with lower baseline reasoning abilities. This indicates that while casual video games may enhance certain cognitive skills, their benefits do not necessarily generalize to broader cognitive functions.
Brain Training Games and Cognitive Functions
Research on commercial brain training games like "Brain Age" and "Lumosity" has produced varied outcomes. A randomized controlled trial found that "Brain Age" improved executive functions, working memory, and processing speed in young adults. Similarly, another study reported significant improvements in attention and memory functions after using "Lumosity" for three weeks. Despite these positive findings, other large-scale studies have failed to demonstrate significant improvements in overall brain function from brain training games. This suggests that while some cognitive benefits may be observed, they are not universally guaranteed.
Meta-Analytic Evidence on Cognitive Training
A comprehensive meta-analysis investigating the effects of video game training on cognitive ability found small or null overall effect sizes. The analysis revealed that video game skill and cognitive ability are only weakly related, and there was no evidence of a causal relationship between playing video games and enhanced cognitive ability. This aligns with findings from other meta-analyses, which have shown that cognitive training benefits are often limited to the tasks practiced and do not generalize to other cognitive domains.
Conclusion
In summary, while brain games and video games can improve specific cognitive skills such as attention, spatial cognition, and processing speed, their ability to make individuals smarter in a general sense is limited. The benefits of these games are often confined to the tasks practiced within the games, with little evidence supporting far transfer to broader cognitive functions. Therefore, while brain games can be a fun and engaging way to exercise certain mental abilities, they should not be relied upon as a sole method for enhancing overall cognitive intelligence. Further research is needed to explore the long-term effects and potential real-world applications of these games.
Sources and full results
Most relevant research papers on this topic