Calculation for tax incidence
Pro Research Analysisby 
Searched over 200M research papers
Consensus Meter
Understanding Tax Incidence: Key Concepts and Calculations
Introduction to Tax Incidence Theory
Tax incidence refers to the analysis of the effect of a particular tax on the distribution of economic welfare among individuals or groups. It determines who ultimately bears the burden of a tax, whether it be consumers, workers, or other factors of production. The theory of tax incidence is crucial for understanding the real economic impact of taxation policies and for designing equitable tax systems.
General Equilibrium and Differential Tax Incidence
The general equilibrium approach to tax incidence considers the entire economy and how taxes affect the allocation of resources and distribution of income. This method examines the differential incidence of various types of taxes, such as general taxes, partial commodity taxes, and partial factor taxes. The analysis often assumes price flexibility, full employment, and constant returns to scale in production, with capital and labor being perfectly shiftable between sectors.
Nonlinear Tax Incidence and Optimal Taxation
Nonlinear tax incidence studies focus on the effects of progressive tax systems, where tax rates increase with income. These studies often use general equilibrium models to show that increasing marginal tax rates on high incomes can sometimes lead to greater overall benefits, contrary to conventional wisdom. This is due to the "trickle-down" effects in the economy, where higher taxes on the wealthy can lead to increased revenue and potentially more equitable income distribution .
Local Fiscal Incidence
At the local level, tax incidence can be analyzed using the Lindahl tax approach, which considers an individual's marginal rate of substitution between public goods and income. This method helps measure the redistributional impact of local budget policies. The sensitivity of Lindahl tax calculations to individual utility functions can be mitigated by using demand curves for public goods estimated through models like the median voter model.
Disequilibrium Models of Tax Incidence
Disequilibrium models provide an alternative perspective by examining tax incidence in economies experiencing excess demand or supply. These models often yield different results compared to equilibrium models, such as showing that the incidence of a partial factor tax falls more heavily on the taxed factor than on the untaxed one. This approach highlights the importance of considering market imbalances when analyzing tax incidence.
Corporate Tax Incidence in Open Economies
Corporate tax incidence in open economies is influenced by various factors, including the elasticity of supply and demand for capital. Studies suggest that capital often bears the majority of the corporate income tax burden. However, the incidence can vary significantly depending on global versus national effects of corporate taxes. In some cases, capital could bear virtually the entire tax burden, even in an open economy.
Lifetime Tax Incidence
Lifetime tax incidence calculations consider the distribution of tax burdens over an individual's lifetime rather than annually. This approach can provide a more accurate picture of the progressivity or regressivity of a tax system. Lifetime incidence calculations often show that income taxes are less progressive over a lifetime compared to annual calculations, while other taxes may be less regressive. This method is more robust to changes in tax allocation assumptions and provides a comprehensive view of tax burdens across different stages of life.
Conclusion
Understanding tax incidence is essential for designing fair and effective tax policies. By analyzing the distribution of tax burdens through various models—whether general equilibrium, nonlinear, local, disequilibrium, or lifetime—policymakers can better assess the real economic impact of taxes and make informed decisions to promote equity and efficiency in the tax system.
Sources and full results
Most relevant research papers on this topic