Can matter change
Pro Research Analysisby 
Searched over 200M research papers
Can Matter Change? An Exploration of States and Transformations
States of Matter: Solid, Liquid, and Gas
Matter exists in three primary states: solid, liquid, and gas. These states are determined by the arrangement and movement of molecules within a substance, influenced by temperature and pressure. When heat is added to a solid, it transitions into a liquid, and with further heating, the liquid becomes a gas. Conversely, cooling a gas will turn it into a liquid, and further cooling will solidify it1.
Aristotle's Perspective on Matter and Change
Aristotle's philosophy provides a foundational understanding of matter and its transformations. He posited that every change involves an underlying substance that persists through the transformation. For instance, when an iron statue is melted and reshaped into cannonballs, the iron remains the constant underlying matter. Aristotle also believed that the basic elements (air, fire, earth, and water) could transform into one another, facilitated by a concept he termed "prime matter"—a fundamental, indeterminate substance that underlies all elemental changes2.
Conceptual Change in Learning Science
Understanding how matter changes is not only a scientific inquiry but also a significant educational challenge. Conceptual change theory suggests that learning new scientific concepts often requires reassigning them from one category to another. For example, students might initially categorize light as matter, but scientific understanding reclassifies it as a process. This shift can be difficult if the initial and scientific conceptions are ontologically distinct3. Effective science education must address these conceptual obstacles to facilitate deeper understanding6 9.
Traditional and Modern Views of Matter
Historically, the view of matter has evolved significantly. Traditional perspectives often faced challenges, such as reconciling the mind-body problem and integrating evolutionary principles. Modern science continues to refine these views, emphasizing the dynamic and process-oriented nature of matter4 10.
Educational Approaches to Teaching Matter
Educational strategies for teaching about matter and its changes have been developed to enhance student understanding. For instance, a reliable achievement test for 5th-grade students was created to assess their grasp of matter-changing concepts, ensuring that the questions were of intermediate difficulty and well-distinguished5. Additionally, studies have shown that students' understanding of matter changes improves with age and education level, though misconceptions about the kinetic theory and particle behavior often persist7.
Conclusion
Matter can indeed change, transitioning between solid, liquid, and gas states under varying conditions of temperature and pressure. Aristotle's philosophical insights and modern educational theories both contribute to our understanding of these transformations. Effective teaching strategies are crucial for overcoming conceptual obstacles and fostering a deeper comprehension of the dynamic nature of matter.
Sources and full results
Most relevant research papers on this topic
From things to processes: A theory of conceptual change for learning science concepts
Conceptual change is easier when initial and scientific conceptions are compatible, but more challenging when they are distinct.
Highly CitedOn Changes of Traditional View of Matter
The traditional view of matter needs changes to address the mind-body problem, two-sided theory, evolutionism, and the mind-body problem.
Development of Achievement Test: Validity and Reliability Study for Achievement Test on Matter Changing.
The developed achievement test for the "Matter Changing" unit in the Secondary School 5th Grade Science Program is effective and reliable, with an intermediate difficulty level and well distinction strength.
Observational StudyModeling Pupils' Understanding and Explanations Concerning Changes in Matter
Pupils' models of matter and changes in matter involve a variety of conceptions, which can be used to design and evaluate constructivist teaching and appropriate materials.
Observational StudyRelationships between everyday knowledge and scientific knowledge: understanding how matter changes
Students' understanding of kinetic theory in explaining matter changes is influenced by age, instruction level, and content, with the main confusion stemming from a failure to differentiate between reality and the scientific models they learn.
Observational StudyTEACHING AND LEARNING ABOUT MATTER IN GRADE 6 CLASSROOMS: A CONCEPTUAL CHANGE APPROACH
A conceptual change approach in grade 6 science teaching enhances students' understanding of matter and its properties, while also improving teachers' content knowledge and teaching strategies.
Non-RCT