Collagen peptides vs protein powder
Pro Research Analysisby 
Searched over 200M research papers
Consensus Meter
Collagen Peptides vs. Protein Powder: A Comparative Analysis
Muscle Growth and Thickness: Whey Protein vs. Collagen Peptides
When it comes to increasing muscle thickness, whey protein (WP) has been shown to be more effective than collagen peptides (CP). A study involving untrained young adults who underwent a 10-week resistance training program found that those supplemented with WP experienced greater increases in muscle thickness of the vastus lateralis and biceps brachii compared to those supplemented with leucine-matched CP. Specifically, the WP group saw an 8.4% increase in vastus lateralis thickness and a 10.1% increase in biceps brachii thickness, whereas the CP group saw increases of 5.6% and 6.0%, respectively. This suggests that WP is superior to CP in promoting muscle hypertrophy.
Muscle Damage and Recovery: Combined Supplementation
In terms of muscle damage and recovery, combining collagen peptides with whey protein does not seem to offer additional benefits over whey protein alone. A study on fit males undergoing eccentric exercise training found no significant differences in muscle damage indices or recovery of muscular performance between those supplemented with whey protein alone and those supplemented with a combination of whey protein and collagen peptides. This indicates that substituting a portion of whey protein with collagen peptides does not enhance recovery outcomes.
Body Composition and Muscle Strength: Collagen Peptides in Elderly
Collagen peptides have shown promise in improving body composition and muscle strength, particularly in elderly individuals with sarcopenia. A 12-week resistance training program combined with collagen peptide supplementation resulted in significant increases in fat-free mass (FFM), muscle strength, and reductions in fat mass (FM) compared to a placebo group. The collagen peptide group experienced a more pronounced increase in FFM (+4.2 kg vs. +2.9 kg) and muscle strength (+16.5 Nm vs. +7.3 Nm). This suggests that collagen peptides can be particularly beneficial for older adults looking to improve muscle mass and strength.
Skeletal Muscle Proteome: Collagen Peptides and Resistance Training
Further supporting the benefits of collagen peptides, another study found that collagen peptide supplementation in combination with resistance training led to a more significant increase in body mass (BM), FFM, and muscle strength compared to a placebo. The study also identified a higher abundance of proteins associated with muscle contractile fibers in the collagen peptide group, indicating enhanced muscle protein metabolism. This highlights the potential of collagen peptides to support muscle growth and strength through improved protein synthesis.
Skin Health: Collagen Peptides for Elasticity
Beyond muscle health, collagen peptides have also been shown to improve skin properties. A study on the effects of collagen peptides enriched with specific amino acids (X-Hyp or X-Hyp-Gly) demonstrated significant improvements in skin elasticity and collagen synthesis in the dermis. Participants who consumed these enriched collagen peptides showed a substantial increase in skin elasticity and collagen content compared to those who consumed normal collagen hydrolysates. This suggests that collagen peptides can also be beneficial for enhancing skin health.
Conclusion
In summary, while whey protein appears to be more effective than collagen peptides for increasing muscle thickness in young adults, collagen peptides offer significant benefits for improving body composition and muscle strength in elderly individuals. Additionally, collagen peptides can enhance skin health by improving elasticity and collagen synthesis. Combining collagen peptides with whey protein does not seem to provide additional benefits for muscle recovery. Therefore, the choice between collagen peptides and protein powder should be tailored to individual goals, whether they are muscle hypertrophy, overall body composition, or skin health.
Sources and full results
Most relevant research papers on this topic