Are deep learnings models better than classical models for timeseries forecasting?
Pro Research Analysisby 
Searched over 200M research papers
Consensus Meter
Deep Learning vs. Classical Models for Time Series Forecasting
Introduction to Time Series Forecasting
Time series forecasting is a critical task in various domains, including finance, weather prediction, and load forecasting. Traditional models like ARIMA have been widely used, but the advent of deep learning has introduced new possibilities. This article explores whether deep learning models outperform classical models in time series forecasting.
Performance of Deep Learning Models
Accuracy and Efficiency
Recent studies indicate that deep learning models, particularly Long Short-Term Memory (LSTM) and Convolutional Neural Networks (CNN), often outperform traditional models in terms of accuracy and efficiency. For instance, LSTMs have been shown to provide the most accurate forecasts, while CNNs offer comparable performance with less variability and higher efficiency. Additionally, a study comparing deep learning models with the Seasonal ARIMAX model found that a gated 24-hour CNN model improved forecasting accuracy by 22.6%.
Handling Complex Non-linear Relationships
Deep learning models excel in capturing complex non-linear relationships in time series data, which traditional models struggle with. This capability makes them particularly effective for multi-step forecasting tasks. For example, a novel model named SeriesNet, which combines LSTM and dilated causal convolution networks, has demonstrated higher predictive accuracy and stability compared to traditional models.
Challenges and Improvements in Deep Learning Models
Model Complexity and Computational Efficiency
Despite their advantages, deep learning models come with challenges such as model complexity and computational efficiency. Selecting the appropriate architecture and hyperparameters requires significant expertise. However, techniques like fine-grained attention mechanisms and ensemble methods have been proposed to enhance the performance of existing deep learning models.
Ensuring Reliability and Robustness
Ensuring the reliability of deep learning models is crucial. A novel validation framework has been introduced to enhance the accuracy, efficiency, and reliability of these models by enforcing stationarity and rejecting autocorrelation in the model's errors. This framework has shown significant improvements in forecasting performance across various domains, including finance and energy.
Comparative Studies with Classical Models
Financial Time Series Forecasting
In financial time series forecasting, deep learning models have significantly outperformed traditional machine learning counterparts. A comprehensive review of deep learning studies in this field highlights the superior performance of models like CNNs, Deep Belief Networks (DBNs), and LSTMs. Additionally, combining deep learning with multiresolution analysis has been shown to improve forecasting accuracy for stock prices.
Weather and Load Forecasting
Deep learning models have also been effective in weather and load forecasting. For instance, a lightweight LSTM and Temporal Convolutional Network (TCN) model outperformed traditional statistical and machine learning approaches in weather forecasting. Similarly, deep learning models have shown better performance in day-ahead building-level load forecasts compared to classical time-series techniques.
Conclusion
Overall, deep learning models generally outperform classical models in time series forecasting, particularly in handling complex non-linear relationships and multi-step forecasting tasks. While challenges such as model complexity and computational efficiency exist, ongoing research and novel techniques continue to enhance the performance and reliability of deep learning models. As a result, deep learning is becoming the preferred choice for time series forecasting across various domains.
Sources and full results
Most relevant research papers on this topic