Depression meds not working
Pro Research Analysisby 
Searched over 200M research papers
Understanding Why Depression Medications May Not Work
Efficacy of Antidepressants in Adults with Major Depression
Antidepressants are widely prescribed for major depression, and numerous studies have shown that they are generally more effective than placebos. A comprehensive review involving 522 trials and 116,477 participants found that certain antidepressants, such as agomelatine, amitriptyline, escitalopram, mirtazapine, paroxetine, venlafaxine, and vortioxetine, were more effective than others1. However, the overall effect size was moderate, suggesting that while these medications can be beneficial, they may not work for everyone. This highlights the need for personalized treatment plans and further research to identify which patients are most likely to benefit from specific antidepressants1.
Placebo Effect and Antidepressant Efficacy
The placebo effect plays a significant role in the perceived efficacy of antidepressants. Research by Professor Kirsch has shown that the placebo effect in depressed individuals can be twice as large as the drug effect, raising questions about the true efficacy of these medications2. Kirsch's meta-analysis revealed that less than a quarter of the antidepressant response is due to the drug itself, with the rest attributed to the placebo effect2. This finding is supported by another study that found the mean difference between patients taking SSRIs and those taking placebos was below the level of clinical significance for mild to moderate depression3.
Treatment-Resistant Depression
A significant challenge in treating depression is the high rate of non-response to antidepressants. Studies indicate that nearly two-thirds of patients with major depression do not achieve remission after a 4-6 week trial of antidepressants, and more than 30% are considered treatment-resistant4. This underscores the need for new therapeutic agents and models for understanding depression. Recent advancements include the development of drugs targeting different neurotransmitter pathways, such as brexanolone for post-partum depression and orexin receptor antagonists4.
Limitations and Risks of Antidepressants
Despite their widespread use, antidepressants have several limitations. They often have delayed therapeutic onset, can be intolerable for some patients, and are less effective for milder forms of depression5. Additionally, there are concerns about the increased risk of suicidal events and the lack of evidence that these medications improve quality of life or help patients return to work7. These issues highlight the importance of weighing the risks and benefits of antidepressants and considering alternative treatments.
Alternative and Augmentative Treatments
Given the limitations of antidepressants, alternative treatments such as psychological therapies are crucial. For instance, dialectical behavior therapy (DBT) has shown promise in augmenting the effects of antidepressant medication in older adults. A study found that patients receiving both antidepressants and DBT had higher remission rates and significant improvements in coping skills compared to those receiving medication alone10. This suggests that combining medication with psychotherapy may enhance treatment outcomes for some patients.
Conclusion
While antidepressants can be effective for many individuals with major depression, their efficacy is not universal, and the placebo effect plays a significant role in their perceived benefits. High rates of treatment-resistant depression and the limitations of current medications underscore the need for personalized treatment approaches and the development of new therapeutic agents. Combining antidepressants with psychological therapies like DBT may offer a more effective treatment strategy for some patients.
Sources and full results
Most relevant research papers on this topic
Editorial Perspective: Antidepressants and the depressed adolescent.
Antidepressants are clinically effective for adults with major depression, but who benefits, how they work, and long-term management remain unresolved.
Systematic ReviewThe Emperor's new drugs: Exploding the antidepressant myth
Antidepressants do not work for depression, and the placebo effect may be twice as large as the drug effect, with psychological therapy being the most effective treatment.
Highly CitedThe drugs don't work for everyone
Antidepressants work for some people with mild to moderate depression, but not for all.
Investigational Drugs for the Treatment of Depression (Part 1): Monoaminergic, Orexinergic, GABA-Ergic, and Anti-Inflammatory Agents
New treatments targeting different neurotransmitter pathways and inflammatory pathways are needed to improve response rates in uni- and bipolar depression.
The drugs don’t work? antidepressants and the current and future pharmacological management of depression
Antidepressants offer benefits in the short and long term, but their efficacy in treating depression remains debated due to intolerability, delayed therapeutic onset, limited efficacy in milder depression, and treatment-resistant depression.
Highly CitedWhy take depression pills if they don't help?
Antidepressants may not be effective for children and teenagers with major depression, but they may be beneficial for adults with mild or moderate depression.
What does “work” mean in the case of antidepressants?
Antidepressants may work for some patients, but their risks outweigh their benefits and their effectiveness is often unclear.
Rigorous JournalPlacebo for treating depression . . . and other stories
Placebo consistently works for 35-40% of depression patients, and all antidepressant drugs should be judged by their number needed to treat beyond placebo, balanced against harm.
Systematic ReviewRigorous JournalExperimental medication treatment approaches for depression
Experimental medications targeting glutamatergic, cholinergic, and opioid systems show potential for treating depression, particularly in treatment-resistant patients.
Very Rigorous JournalDialectical behavior therapy for depressed older adults: a randomized pilot study.
Dialectical behavior therapy skills training and telephone coaching may effectively augment the effects of antidepressant medication in depressed older adults.
RCTHighly Cited