Do protein shakes make u fat
Pro Research Analysisby 
Searched over 200M research papers
Consensus Meter
Do Protein Shakes Make You Fat?
Protein Shakes and Weight Management
Protein shakes are often marketed as a tool for weight management, but do they actually contribute to weight gain? Research indicates that protein shakes, when consumed as part of a balanced diet, do not inherently cause weight gain and may even support weight loss and improved metabolic health.
High-Protein Shakes and Weight Loss
Several studies have shown that high-protein shakes can aid in weight loss. For instance, a 12-week study involving overweight and obese adults found that participants who consumed a high-protein, high-fiber shake twice daily experienced greater weight loss compared to those who consumed a low-protein, low-fiber placebo shake. The high-protein group lost an average of 3.3 kg, while the placebo group lost 1.8 kg . This suggests that protein shakes, particularly those high in protein and fiber, can be effective in promoting weight loss.
Acute Effects on Body Composition
Another study examined the immediate effects of consuming a protein shake versus water on body composition. The results showed no significant changes in body mass, lean body mass, or fat mass between the two groups over a short period. However, there was a temporary increase in percent body fat immediately after consumption, which normalized within an hour. This indicates that while protein shakes may cause short-term fluctuations in body composition measurements, they do not lead to long-term fat gain.
Protein Source and Weight Loss
The type of protein in the shakes can also influence weight loss outcomes. A study comparing soy and casein protein shakes found that both types led to significant weight loss in obese women over 16 weeks, with no significant differences between the two groups. Participants lost an average of 12.7 kg, demonstrating that both soy and casein protein shakes can be effective for weight loss when combined with an energy-restricted diet.
Resistance Training and Protein Shakes
For older adults, combining protein shakes with resistance training can have additional benefits. A study involving sarcopenic overweight older men found that those who consumed dairy-based protein shakes post-exercise experienced significant decreases in fat mass. This suggests that protein shakes, particularly those containing dairy, can enhance the fat loss effects of resistance training in older adults.
Thermogenic Effects of Protein Shakes
The thermogenic effect of protein shakes, or the increase in energy expenditure following consumption, varies depending on the macronutrient composition. A study comparing different types of low-calorie meal-replacement shakes found that high-protein shakes induced a greater thermogenic response than low-protein, high-carbohydrate shakes. However, the difference in energy expenditure was relatively small and unlikely to have a significant impact on daily energy balance.
Conclusion
In summary, protein shakes do not inherently cause weight gain and can be a useful tool for weight management, especially when they are high in protein and fiber. They can support weight loss, improve metabolic markers, and enhance the effects of resistance training. The type of protein and the overall diet and exercise regimen play crucial roles in determining the effectiveness of protein shakes for weight management.
Sources and full results
Most relevant research papers on this topic