Does immigration increase unemployment?

Introduction

The relationship between immigration and unemployment is a complex and widely debated topic in economic research. Various studies have examined whether immigration leads to higher unemployment rates among native populations, with findings often varying based on the country, time period, and specific economic conditions considered.

Key Insights

Temporary Increase in Unemployment:
- Immigration can lead to a temporary increase in unemployment, particularly in contexts with stringent product market regulations or high unemployment benefits .
No Long-Term Impact:
- In the long run, immigration does not significantly impact the unemployment rate. This is observed in multiple countries, including OECD countries, Canada, France, and Australia .
Short-Term Positive Impact:
- In the short run, immigration can have a positive impact on the unemployment rate due to initial job market integration challenges faced by immigrants .
No Detrimental Effect on Employment:
- Studies from Germany and Australia indicate that immigration does not have a detrimental effect on native employment levels. In some cases, it may even improve employment prospects for unemployed residents .
Impact on Racial Minorities:
- In the United States, increased immigration has been found to negatively affect employment levels among racial minorities during certain historical periods.
Labor Market Transitions:
- Immigration does not significantly affect the probabilities of native-born workers finding a job but is associated with higher probabilities of workers leaving the labor force, particularly among young and less educated individuals.

Conclusion

Overall, the research suggests that while immigration may cause a temporary increase in unemployment due to initial integration challenges, it does not have a significant long-term impact on unemployment rates. In some contexts, immigration can even improve employment prospects for native workers. The effects can vary based on specific economic conditions and policies in place, but fears of immigration causing sustained high unemployment are largely unfounded.

Does immigration increase unemployment?

Summary

Consensus Meter

Introduction

Key Insights

Conclusion

Sources and full results

The unemployment impact of immigration in OECD countries

Immigration in OECD countries has no significant long-term impact on unemployment, but may temporarily increase it depending on the policy framework.

The relationship between immigration and unemployment: Panel data evidence from Canada

In the short run, immigration in Canada increases unemployment, but in the long run, immigrants' employment prospects improve and the negative impact on unemployment is eliminated.

The impact of immigration on unemployment and earnings among racial minorities in the United States

Increases in immigration in some periods of US history had significant negative effects on employment levels among racial minorities, with 1970 and 1980 showing increases of nearly 14 and 10 percent respectively.

IMMIGRATION AND UNEMPLOYMENT: A MACROECONOMIC APPROACH

Unanticipated increases in immigration can lead to temporary increases in unemployment under various conditions, consistent with postwar US data.

The Relationship between Immigration and Unemployment: The Case of France

Immigration in France leads to lower unemployment and weak positive effects on employment in the long run, with migration flows having weak effects on employment despite institutional differences.

Immigration and Unemployment

No evidence links migration to unemployment in post-war Australia, suggesting immigration policy should not be influenced by unfounded fears of migration causing unemployment.

Unemployed, Now What? The Effect of Immigration on Unemployment Transitions of Native-Born Workers in the United States

Immigration reduces unemployment but also increases the likelihood of workers leaving the labor force, primarily impacting young and less educated individuals.

Employment Effects of Immigration to Germany: An Analysis Based on Local Labor Markets

Increased immigration to Germany did not negatively impact employment outcomes for natives, and the absence of displacement effects was not due to native migration patterns.

A Comparative Static Model of the Relationship between Immigration and the Short-Run Job Prospects of Unemployed Residents

Immigration generally increases short-run job prospects for unemployed residents, but the effect is more pronounced in a recessed labor market.

Immigration and the natural rate of unemployment in Australia

Decreased immigration to Australia during the early 1960s did not significantly increase the unemployment rate associated with a given level of labor demand.

Try another search