Does inquiry based learning improve critical thinking
Pro Research Analysisby 
Searched over 200M research papers
Consensus Meter
Inquiry-Based Learning and Its Impact on Critical Thinking Skills
Introduction to Inquiry-Based Learning
Inquiry-based learning (IBL) is an educational approach that emphasizes the student's role in the learning process, allowing them to follow their curiosity, ask questions, and explore topics in depth. This method contrasts with traditional teaching methods, which often involve direct instruction and rote memorization. The primary goal of IBL is to foster a deeper understanding of the subject matter and develop critical thinking skills.
Enhancing Critical Thinking Skills through Inquiry-Based Learning
Positive Impact on Critical Thinking
Multiple studies have demonstrated that inquiry-based learning significantly enhances students' critical thinking skills. For instance, research involving EFL undergraduate students showed that inquiry-based argumentative writing instruction improved their critical thinking abilities, including interpretation, analysis, evaluation, inference, explanation, and self-regulation skills. Similarly, a study on prospective teachers found that those who engaged in IBL exhibited a more substantial increase in critical thinking skills compared to those who followed a problem-based learning approach.
Comparative Studies and Meta-Analyses
A literature review and meta-analysis of various studies confirmed the effectiveness of the inquiry learning model in improving students' critical thinking skills. The analysis revealed a significant difference in critical thinking abilities between students who used the inquiry learning model and those who did not. Another study focusing on science and technology courses found that students taught with guided inquiry activities showed higher levels of critical thinking compared to those taught with traditional methods.
Subject-Specific Applications
Inquiry-based learning has also been applied successfully in specific subjects to enhance critical thinking. For example, in a study involving junior high school students, the implementation of a science context-based inquiry learning model (SCOIL) led to significant improvements in critical thinking skills compared to a guided inquiry learning model. Additionally, the development and application of an inquiry learning model with science literacy in a chemistry course improved students' critical thinking and academic achievement.
Challenges and Considerations
Variability in Effectiveness
While many studies highlight the benefits of IBL, some research indicates that its effectiveness can vary. For instance, a study on pre-service science teachers found no statistically significant difference in critical thinking dispositions between those who participated in IBL and those who did not. This suggests that the success of IBL may depend on various factors, including the implementation method, the subject matter, and the students' initial critical thinking levels.
Learning Styles and Adaptation
The effectiveness of IBL can also be influenced by students' learning styles. Research on prospective teachers showed that those with converging learning styles were more adept at following the IBL method compared to others. This highlights the need for educators to consider individual learning preferences when designing and implementing IBL activities.
Conclusion
Overall, inquiry-based learning has been shown to significantly improve critical thinking skills across various educational contexts and subjects. While its effectiveness can vary based on implementation and individual differences, the evidence suggests that IBL is a valuable pedagogical approach for fostering critical thinking. Educators are encouraged to incorporate IBL strategies into their teaching to enhance students' analytical and evaluative abilities, preparing them for complex problem-solving and decision-making tasks.
Sources and full results
Most relevant research papers on this topic