All embryos start as female
Pro Research Analysisby 
Searched over 200M research papers
Consensus Meter
Do All Embryos Start as Female?
Introduction to Embryonic Sex Differentiation
The question of whether all embryos start as female has intrigued scientists for decades. Research in embryology and genetics has provided insights into the early stages of embryonic development and sex differentiation. This article synthesizes findings from multiple studies to address this question.
Genetic Sex Determination at Fertilization
Genetic sex is established at the moment of fertilization. The presence of XX chromosomes results in a female, while XY chromosomes result in a male. However, the influence of these sex genes does not manifest until the fifth to sixth week of fetal life. During this period, the development of the gonads and the production of sex-specific hormones begin to shape the physical characteristics of the embryo.
Early Embryo Development and Female Characteristics
French endocrinologist Jost's research in the 1950s concluded that the early embryo is not undifferentiated but is inherently female. This means that in the absence of male-specific signals, the embryo will develop female characteristics by default. If the genetic sex is female, the germ cells migrate to the gonadal cortex, forming ovaries and producing fetal estrogen. Even if the ovaries do not develop, the fetus will still exhibit female characteristics, although with abnormalities.
Male Embryo Development and Androgen Influence
For male embryos, the primordial germ cells migrate to the gonadal medulla, where they stimulate the production of a "testicular inductor substance." This substance triggers the production of fetal androgens, which suppress the development of female structures and promote the growth of male genitalia. The presence and proper functioning of androgens are crucial for the development of male characteristics.
Embryo Morphokinetics and Sex Differences
Studies using time-lapse technology have explored whether there are differences in the development kinetics of male and female embryos. Some research indicates that male embryos may develop faster in certain stages compared to female embryos . For instance, male embryos have been observed to reach the three-cell stage (t3) and subsequent stages more quickly than female embryos. However, these differences are not always statistically significant and can vary between studies.
Female Bias in Embryonic Stem Cell Lines
Interestingly, there is a notable female bias in the derivation of human embryonic stem cell (HESC) lines. A significant increase in female cell lines has been observed, which is attributed to suboptimal culture conditions rather than a true gender imbalance in the embryos used for derivation. This suggests that female embryos may be more resilient or adaptable to the conditions used in stem cell research.
Conclusion
In summary, while genetic sex is determined at fertilization, the early embryo exhibits female characteristics by default. The development of male characteristics requires specific signals and hormones that suppress female structures and promote male genitalia. Differences in embryo development kinetics between sexes have been observed, but these findings are not always consistent. The female bias in HESC lines further highlights the complexity of embryonic development and sex differentiation.
Sources and full results
Most relevant research papers on this topic