Hydration efficacy of different beverages
Pro Research Analysisby 
Searched over 200M research papers
Hydration Efficacy: Comparing Different Beverages Using the Beverage Hydration Index
Electrolyte and Carbohydrate Beverages vs. Water
Research consistently shows that beverages containing electrolytes and carbohydrates can improve hydration compared to water alone. When consumed at similar rates, electrolyte beverages significantly reduce urine output and increase the beverage hydration index (BHI), a measure of fluid retention, compared to water. For example, one study found that a commercial electrolyte beverage decreased cumulative urine output by 32% compared to water and increased BHI by 64% after six hours, indicating superior hydration efficacy 14. Similarly, carbohydrate-electrolyte drinks have been shown to provide higher BHI values than water, especially within the first two hours after ingestion 39.
Impact of Beverage Composition: Isomaltulose vs. Sucrose
The type of carbohydrate in a beverage also affects hydration. Beverages containing isomaltulose, a low-glycemic carbohydrate, resulted in greater fluid retention and a higher BHI compared to those with sucrose or water. Isomaltulose beverages attenuated urine production more effectively, likely due to delayed absorption, which reduces diuresis and helps maintain hydration .
Role of Electrolytes, Protein, and Amino Acids
Electrolyte content is a key factor in enhancing hydration. Drinks with higher sodium concentrations progressively increase BHI, and the addition of amino acids or protein can further improve fluid retention, especially in older adults 37. However, the combination of electrolytes with either carbohydrate or protein does not always result in significant differences in hydration status when electrolyte levels are equivalent . Electrolyte drinks are also more effective in maintaining physiological balance during and after exercise compared to water, juice, tea, or carbonated beverages .
Milk and Oral Rehydration Solutions
Milk (both full-fat and skimmed) and oral rehydration solutions (ORS) have been found to outperform water and many other common beverages in promoting fluid retention. These drinks have higher BHI values, indicating they are retained longer in the body and are more effective for hydration over several hours .
Caffeinated and Non-Caffeinated Beverages
Contrary to common belief, moderate consumption of caffeinated beverages such as coffee, cola, and tea does not significantly differ from water in terms of hydration status. Studies show no significant differences in body weight changes or biochemical hydration markers between caffeinated and non-caffeinated drinks, suggesting that these beverages can contribute to daily fluid intake .
Subjective Thirst vs. Physiological Hydration
While electrolyte drinks are more effective in maintaining physiological hydration, water is rated highest for alleviating subjective thirst. This indicates that the sensation of thirst does not always align with physiological hydration markers, highlighting the need for comprehensive evaluation when choosing beverages for hydration .
Conclusion
Beverages containing electrolytes and carbohydrates, especially those with isomaltulose or higher sodium content, are generally more effective than water alone for maintaining hydration. Milk and oral rehydration solutions also provide superior fluid retention. Caffeinated beverages do not negatively impact hydration when consumed in moderation. However, the best beverage for subjective thirst relief may still be plain water. The choice of beverage should consider both physiological hydration and personal comfort.
Sources and full results
Most relevant research papers on this topic