If the universe is expanding what is it expanding into
Pro Research Analysisby 
Searched over 200M research papers
The Expanding Universe: What is it Expanding Into?
Understanding the Expansion of the Universe
The concept of the expanding universe is a cornerstone of modern cosmology. Observations, such as the redshift of distant galaxies, have confirmed that the universe is expanding2 7. However, this raises a fundamental question: what is the universe expanding into?
The Nature of Space and Expansion
Expanding Space vs. Static Space
The expansion of the universe is often described using the concept of "expanding space." This idea, while mathematically significant, does not imply that the universe is expanding into a pre-existing space. Instead, it suggests that the distances between objects within the universe are increasing6. This can be contrasted with a static space model, where the expansion is viewed as the motion of particles within a fixed space6.
Infinite Euclidean Space
One perspective is that the universe could be expanding within an infinite Euclidean space. This means that the universe does not have a boundary or edge into which it is expanding. Instead, the expansion is a result of the initial density distribution of matter, which extends throughout infinite space3.
The Role of General Relativity
Curvature of Space
General relativity provides a framework for understanding the expansion of the universe. According to Einstein's theory, the universe can have different geometries, including flat, open, or closed. The curvature of space is determined by the distribution of matter and energy2. Recent work suggests that space itself may not have any inherent curvature, allowing for a series of expansions and contractions over time2.
De Sitter Phase
In the currently accepted cosmological model (ΛCDM), the universe is expanding at a decreasing rate, approaching a de Sitter phase where the expansion rate becomes constant. This phase implies that the universe will continue to expand indefinitely, but the rate of expansion will stabilize1.
Theoretical Implications
Thermodynamic Perspective
Some theories suggest that the expansion of the universe could be linked to thermodynamic principles. For instance, the instability arising from the "wrong" sign in the Hilbert action for the kinetic energy term might drive the expansion. This idea connects the thermodynamic and cosmological arrows of time, providing a speculative but plausible scenario for the universe's expansion4.
Asymptotic Behavior
The asymptotic behavior of the universe's expansion can be described using solutions to the Einstein equations. These solutions help determine the possible forms for the time evolution of the expansion scale factor, which is crucial for understanding the long-term behavior of the universe8.
Conclusion
The universe's expansion is a complex phenomenon that does not imply it is expanding into anything. Instead, the expansion is an intrinsic property of the universe itself, driven by the initial conditions and governed by the laws of general relativity. The concept of expanding space, infinite Euclidean space, and the role of thermodynamic principles all contribute to our understanding of this cosmic expansion. As our knowledge of cosmology advances, we continue to refine our models and theories to better comprehend the nature of the universe and its expansion.
Sources and full results
Most relevant research papers on this topic
What Expands in an Expanding Universe?
The acceleration of the expanding background is the determinant factor affecting planetary orbits and atomic sizes in bonded systems, with all bonded systems expanding at a decreasing rate towards zero in a de Sitter phase.
Expansion of the Universe
The universe is expanding, but the rate of expansion cannot easily reconcile with an evolutionary age of 1010 years.
Highly CitedWhy does the universe expand?
The universe expands due to the instability arising from the 'wrong' sign in the Hilbert action for the kinetic energy term corresponding to expansion factor, potentially linking thermodynamic and cosmological arrows of time.
The Expanding Universe
The stars are older than the universe, suggesting the "beginning of the universe" was just a minimum separation of galaxies, with the earth possibly being formed at the beginning but the sun not.
Highly CitedA Newtonian Expanding Universe
A Newtonian expanding universe is a static universe in which moving particles exhibit the same observable phenomena as stationary particles in 'expanding' space, with the expansion occurring due to the gravitational force of attraction between matter and space.
Highly Cited