Do males start out as females
Pro Research Analysisby 
Searched over 200M research papers
Consensus Meter
Do Males Start Out as Females?
Introduction to Sex Differentiation
Sex differentiation is a complex biological process that determines whether an organism will develop male or female characteristics. This process is influenced by genetic, hormonal, and environmental factors. The question of whether males start out as females touches on the fundamental aspects of developmental biology and sex determination.
Protandry in Insects: Males Emerging Before Females
In many insect species, including butterflies, there is a phenomenon known as protandry, where males emerge before females. This is considered a reproductive strategy to maximize mating opportunities, especially in species where females are monogamous. Protandry does not imply that males start out as females but rather that males develop and mature earlier than females for strategic reproductive advantages.
Developmental History and Sex Preferences in Fish
In the context of fish, particularly the mosquitofish (Gambusia holbrooki), males that experience a poor start in life due to restricted diets can undergo compensatory growth. This allows them to reach a similar size to those that developed normally, although females tend to prefer males that did not undergo compensatory growth. This study highlights how early developmental conditions can influence later sexual attractiveness but does not suggest that males start out as females.
Genetic Males Assigned Female at Birth
A study on genetic males with severe phallic inadequacy assigned female at birth provides insights into gender identity and psychosocial development. The study found that many of these individuals, despite being raised as females, eventually identified and lived as males. This indicates that genetic and biological factors play a significant role in gender identity, but it does not support the notion that males start out as females.
Sex Differences in Psychopathology
Research into sex differences in psychopathology reveals that males and females have different susceptibilities to various disorders, influenced by genetic, hormonal, and environmental factors. This research underscores the complexity of sex differentiation and the varied consequences of being male or female but does not address the idea that males start out as females.
Conclusion
The concept that males start out as females is not supported by the current research. While there are complex interactions between genetics, development, and environmental factors that influence sex differentiation and gender identity, the studies reviewed do not provide evidence that males begin life as females. Instead, they highlight the distinct developmental pathways and strategies that males and females undergo in various species.
Sources and full results
Most relevant research papers on this topic