How to measure impact of change
Pro Research Analysisby 
Searched over 200M research papers
Consensus Meter
Measuring the Impact of Change: Methods and Approaches
Introduction to Change Impact Analysis
Change impact analysis (CIA) is a critical process in various fields, including software development, environmental studies, and health assessments. It involves evaluating the potential consequences of changes to predict and manage their effects efficiently. This article synthesizes research on different methodologies for measuring the impact of change, highlighting key approaches and their effectiveness.
Software Development: Model-Based and Dynamic Impact Analysis
Model-Based Impact Analysis
In software development, performing impact analysis before implementing changes is crucial for maintaining system integrity. A model-based approach, particularly for state-based systems like telecommunication or embedded systems, uses model dependencies to measure the expected impact of changes. This method generates two impact sets representing the lower and upper bounds of the impact, allowing early identification of critical components before actual code changes are made. Empirical studies show that the size of the impact after a single modification ranges between 14% and 38% of the total model size, while multiple modifications can affect 30% to 64% of the model.
Dynamic Impact Analysis
Dynamic impact analysis identifies potential impacts of changes during program execution. However, its accuracy can be problematic. Studies reveal that dynamic impact analysis often suffers from low precision (38-50%) and recall (50-56%), indicating that it may not reliably predict the actual impacts of changes. This highlights the need for more accurate and cost-effective impact analysis techniques in software development.
Environmental Impact Assessment: Temporal and Spatial Variation
Intervention Analysis and BACI
Environmental impact assessments often use Intervention Analysis (IA) and Before-After, Control-Impact (BACI) designs to monitor chronic local impacts. IA compares time series data before and after an intervention at an impact site, while BACI uses control sites as covariates to reduce extraneous variance. Both methods aim to determine changes at specific impact sites, with BACI providing a more robust error variance estimation by considering site variations.
Local to Global Aggregation
Measuring environmental impacts from local to global scales involves significant challenges. Aggregating impacts across different commodities, individuals, sectors, regions, and time requires careful consideration of assumptions and methodologies. This process is essential for understanding the broader implications of local changes and making informed decisions at higher scales.
Health and Social Impact: Sensitivity to Change
Autism Impact Measure (AIM)
The Autism Impact Measure (AIM) is designed to assess treatment outcomes in children with Autism Spectrum Disorder (ASD). It has demonstrated strong reliability and validity, with sensitivity to changes in symptoms over short-term treatments. This makes AIM a valuable tool for detecting improvements and guiding treatment decisions.
Stroke Impact Scale (SIS)
The Stroke Impact Scale (SIS) evaluates the impact of strokes on various domains such as strength, mobility, and communication. It has shown high reliability and validity, with responsiveness to changes due to ongoing recovery. This makes SIS a useful measure for clinical research and patient monitoring.
Theory of Change and Health Technology Assessment (HTA)
Theory of Change Framework
The theory of change framework is used to evaluate the impact of health technology assessments (HTA). This approach links causes and effects, explaining how and why impacts occur. It combines economic models to quantify the magnitude of impact with theory-based approaches to understand the mechanisms leading to impact. This comprehensive framework helps policymakers make informed decisions and optimize the use of HTA for better health outcomes.
Conclusion
Measuring the impact of change is a multifaceted process that varies across different fields. In software development, model-based and dynamic impact analyses offer insights into potential consequences of changes, though their accuracy can vary. Environmental impact assessments benefit from robust designs like IA and BACI, while health and social impact measures like AIM and SIS provide reliable and sensitive tools for monitoring changes. The theory of change framework further enhances the understanding of impacts in health technology assessments, guiding better decision-making and policy development.
Sources and full results
Most relevant research papers on this topic