Mouthwash efficacy for dental plaque removal
Pro Research Analysisby 
Searched over 200M research papers
Chlorhexidine, Cetylpyridinium Chloride, and Essential Oils: Efficacy for Dental Plaque Removal
Chlorhexidine (CHX) mouthwash is widely recognized as the "gold standard" for chemical plaque control due to its strong ability to disrupt dental plaque biofilm and reduce plaque accumulation. However, it is also associated with side effects such as tooth staining and taste alteration. Cetylpyridinium chloride (CPC) mouthwash has shown comparable effectiveness to CHX in reducing dental plaque, with studies and meta-analyses indicating no significant difference in plaque reduction between the two. CPC is also generally better tolerated, with fewer adverse effects reported. Essential oil (EO) mouthwashes have also demonstrated substantial antiplaque activity, making them useful for maintaining oral hygiene alongside CHX and CPC options 125.
Alternative Mouthwash Ingredients: Chitosan, Propolis, Cannabinoids, and Sodium Chloride
Chitosan-based mouthwashes, when used alone, significantly reduce plaque accumulation and gingival inflammation. However, combining chitosan with CHX appears to be even more effective than using either alone 3. Propolis-based mouthwashes have shown good efficacy in reducing dental plaque and gingivitis, with most studies finding them as effective as CHX, though some report CHX as slightly superior. The evidence for propolis is promising but limited by small sample sizes and study quality 4.
Cannabinoid-infused mouthwashes (containing CBD or CBG) have demonstrated in vitro bactericidal efficacy against dental plaque bacteria that is similar to that of CHX, suggesting potential as effective and safer alternatives for plaque control 7. Mouthwashes containing sodium chloride, green tea extract, and sodium monofluorophosphate have also been shown to significantly reduce dental plaque and improve gingival health compared to control groups 8.
Herbal and Probiotic Mouthwashes: Comparable Short-Term Efficacy
Herbal mouthwashes, including those with ingredients like Triphala, aloe vera, tea tree, and polyherbal blends, have been found to be as effective as non-herbal mouthwashes (such as CHX) in reducing dental plaque in the short term. However, the evidence is based on low-quality trials, and some studies report non-herbal mouthwashes as slightly superior. Probiotic mouthwashes have also shown nearly equal effectiveness to CHX in reducing plaque and bleeding scores, outperforming herbal and povidone-iodine mouthwashes in some studies 910.
Novel Formulations: Amine + Zinc Lactate + Fluoride Systems
A new mouthwash formulation containing amine, zinc lactate, and fluoride has demonstrated long-term antibacterial activity and significant reductions in plaque and gingivitis over several months of use. This formulation increased the number of healthy sites in the mouth and improved overall gum health compared to a negative control, supporting its use for patients with gingivitis 6.
Conclusion
Multiple types of mouthwashes—including those containing chlorhexidine, cetylpyridinium chloride, essential oils, chitosan, propolis, cannabinoids, sodium chloride, herbal ingredients, and probiotics—have demonstrated efficacy in reducing dental plaque. While CHX remains the benchmark, alternatives like CPC, essential oils, and several natural or novel formulations offer comparable plaque control with fewer side effects. The choice of mouthwash can be tailored to individual needs, preferences, and tolerance for side effects, with many options providing effective adjuncts to mechanical plaque removal.
Sources and full results
Most relevant research papers on this topic