Newton vs einstein gravity
Pro Research Analysisby 
Searched over 200M research papers
Newton vs. Einstein: A Comparative Analysis of Gravity Theories
Introduction to Gravity Theories
Gravity has been a central topic in physics, with significant contributions from both Isaac Newton and Albert Einstein. Newton's theory of gravity, formulated in the 17th century, describes gravity as a force between two masses. In contrast, Einstein's General Theory of Relativity, introduced in the early 20th century, conceptualizes gravity as a curvature of space-time caused by mass and energy.
Newtonian Gravity: Force and Mass
Newton's theory of gravity is based on the idea that every mass exerts an attractive force on every other mass. This force is proportional to the product of the two masses and inversely proportional to the square of the distance between them. Newton's laws have been instrumental in understanding and predicting the motion of celestial bodies and have been sufficient for many practical applications in celestial mechanics.
Einstein's General Relativity: Curved Space-Time
Einstein revolutionized our understanding of gravity by proposing that it is not a force but a consequence of the curvature of space-time. According to General Relativity, massive objects cause a distortion in the fabric of space-time, and this curvature directs the motion of objects, including light. This theory has been confirmed by several key experiments, such as the perihelion precession of Mercury, the deflection of light by gravity, and gravitational redshift .
Comparing Newtonian and Einsteinian Gravity
Relativistic Effects and Classical Tests
Einstein's theory has passed several classical tests that Newtonian gravity could not fully explain. For instance, the perihelion precession of Mercury's orbit, the deflection of light by the Sun, and gravitational redshift are phenomena that are accurately described by General Relativity but not by Newtonian mechanics. However, an extension of Newtonian gravity that includes gravitational time dilation can also account for these effects while retaining a non-relativistic causal structure.
Quantum Considerations
Recent developments suggest that Newtonian gravity can be extended to incorporate quantum effects, providing a simpler yet precise calculation of relativistic phenomena. This approach, known as Newtonian Quantum Gravity (NQG), unifies quantum physics with Newton's theory and challenges the necessity of the complex theoretical constructs of General Relativity.
Energy and Gravity
Some researchers argue that gravity should be explained based on energy rather than just mass. This perspective aligns with Einstein's equivalency principle (E = mc^2), suggesting that gravity is a property of energy. This approach attempts to bridge Newtonian concepts with Einstein's equations, proposing that the total energy of a system should be considered when explaining gravitational effects.
Modern Interpretations and Extensions
Subatomic Scale and Planck Masses
New perspectives on gravity at the subatomic scale suggest that both Newton's and Einstein's gravitational formulas can be rewritten to provide new insights. These reformulations could help understand the strengths and weaknesses of each theory when applied to very small masses, potentially revealing hidden aspects such as the speed of gravity being equal to that of light within Newton's formula.
Entropic Gravity
Another modern interpretation proposes that gravity is an entropic force resulting from changes in information associated with the positions of material bodies. This theory suggests that Newton's law of gravitation naturally arises in a holographic scenario, and a relativistic generalization leads directly to Einstein's equations.
Conclusion
Both Newton's and Einstein's theories of gravity have significantly advanced our understanding of the universe. While Newton's laws provide a straightforward and practical approach for many applications, Einstein's General Relativity offers a more comprehensive explanation of gravitational phenomena, especially under extreme conditions. Modern research continues to explore and extend these foundational theories, seeking a deeper understanding of gravity that encompasses both classical and quantum realms.
Sources and full results
Most relevant research papers on this topic