Redistribution and fiscal policy

Pro Research Analysisby

Searched over 200M research papers

Analyzed relevant papers

Consensus Meter

Yes

Possibly

Redistribution and Fiscal Policy: An Overview

Introduction to Redistribution and Fiscal Policy

Redistribution and fiscal policy are critical tools used by governments to manage economic inequality and stimulate economic activity. Redistribution involves reallocating income and wealth from certain groups to others, typically through taxation and public spending. Fiscal policy, on the other hand, encompasses government spending and tax policies aimed at influencing economic conditions. This article synthesizes recent research on the interplay between redistribution and fiscal policy, highlighting key findings and implications.

The Role of Monetary-Fiscal Policy Mix in Redistribution

The effectiveness of redistribution policies is significantly influenced by the monetary-fiscal policy mix. Research indicates that the impact of redistribution on the economy and welfare is closely tied to the inflation it generates, which depends on how the government finances these transfers. Two primary regimes are identified: the monetary regime, where taxes are raised to finance transfers, and the fiscal regime, where inflation taxes are imposed on public debt holders. The fiscal regime tends to generate larger and more persistent inflation, which can counteract deflationary forces during recessions, leading to larger transfer multipliers and milder economic contractions.

Redistribution in Federal Systems

In federal systems like the United States, both state and federal governments play roles in income redistribution. States engage in redistribution despite traditional fiscal federalism literature suggesting that the federal government should primarily handle it. State-level redistribution creates positive horizontal fiscal externalities due to migration and negative vertical fiscal externalities due to changes in reported taxable income. The federal government can adjust its redistribution efforts to balance these externalities, ensuring an effective overall redistribution strategy.

Optimal Fiscal Policy for Redistribution

Optimal fiscal policy for redistribution involves carefully balancing tax rates and transfers. A stochastic dynamic general equilibrium model with heterogeneous agents shows that initial inequality significantly affects both the actual levy and income distribution. The model also suggests a positive correlation between inequality and tax rates, indicating that higher inequality necessitates higher taxes to achieve redistribution goals. Additionally, optimal policies often involve increasing overall transfers and adjusting tax rates on capital and labor income to mitigate intertemporal distortions and enhance welfare.

Determinants of State and Local Fiscal Redistribution

State and local governments' choices in fiscal redistribution are influenced by various factors, including urbanization, poverty levels, and demographic characteristics. Less urbanized and poorer states tend to emphasize redistributive expenditures and revenues more. States with larger elderly and black populations also focus more on redistributive policies. These governments use revenue and expenditure distribution instruments as complements to achieve their redistribution goals.

Fiscal Redistribution in Developed Countries

Fiscal redistribution in developed countries varies significantly, driven by differences in the magnitude and progressivity of transfers. The effectiveness of redistribution is influenced by the size and targeting efficiency of social benefits. Detailed data from the Luxembourg Income Study reveals that both taxes and transfers play crucial roles in achieving redistribution, with trends showing varying degrees of effectiveness across countries and over time.

Impact of Fiscal Policy on Economic Inequality

State fiscal policies can significantly influence economic inequality. Spending on unemployment compensation and cash assistance, as well as revenue from corporate taxes, tends to reduce state-level inequality. Conversely, higher property tax revenue is associated with decreased income for all groups. These findings suggest that state governments can use fiscal policies to affect redistribution and economic inequality, benefiting different income groups in various ways.

Conclusion

Redistribution and fiscal policy are essential tools for managing economic inequality and stimulating economic activity. The effectiveness of these policies depends on the monetary-fiscal policy mix, the roles of federal and state governments, and the specific fiscal instruments used. By understanding these dynamics, policymakers can design more effective strategies to achieve redistribution and improve economic welfare.