Side effects of lean
Pro Research Analysisby 
Searched over 200M research papers
Side Effects of Lean Management: A Comprehensive Analysis
Introduction to Lean Management Side Effects
Lean Management, while widely adopted for its efficiency and cost-saving benefits, has been associated with several negative side effects. These side effects can manifest in various forms, impacting both organizational performance and employee well-being. This article synthesizes findings from multiple research studies to provide a comprehensive overview of the adverse effects linked to Lean Management implementations.
Increased Costs and Quality Issues
Unplanned Financial and Quality Impacts
Despite the primary goal of Lean Management being cost reduction and efficiency improvement, several studies have reported unplanned negative financial impacts and quality issues. Empirical evidence from the European machine tools industry indicates that while initial cost savings and productivity gains are achieved, these are often followed by increased costs and quality problems over time1 2. This suggests that the benefits of Lean Management may be short-lived and can lead to long-term financial and operational challenges.
Health and Safety Concerns
Musculoskeletal and Psychosocial Risks
Lean production environments have been shown to negatively affect occupational health, particularly in terms of musculoskeletal and psychosocial risks. Studies over the past 20 years have consistently found that the Just-In-Time (JIT) production characteristic of Lean systems increases work pace and reduces recovery time, leading to higher incidences of musculoskeletal disorders and stress3. The automotive industry, in particular, has reported significant negative health outcomes due to the intensified work demands and reduced decision latitude associated with Lean practices5.
Job Strain and Ergonomic Stressors
The introduction of Lean Management in various industries, including healthcare, has been linked to job strain and ergonomic stressors. Lean practices often lead to an intensified work pace and increased demands, which can exacerbate job strain and contribute to musculoskeletal disorders5 8. This is particularly concerning in jobs with existing ergonomic stressors, where the additional pressure from Lean practices can lead to significant health issues.
Customer Dissatisfaction
Delayed Negative Effects on Customer Satisfaction
Another critical side effect of Lean Management is customer dissatisfaction. While Lean practices aim to improve efficiency and service delivery, the unplanned negative effects, such as quality issues and increased costs, can ultimately lead to customer dissatisfaction. This delayed negative impact on customer satisfaction has been observed in multiple case studies within the machine building industries in Europe1 2 4.
Work Intensification and Employee Well-being
Mixed Effects on Job Satisfaction and Productivity
The impact of Lean Management on employee well-being and job satisfaction is complex and varies across different contexts. In some cases, Lean practices have been found to intensify work, leading to increased stress and reduced job satisfaction. However, there are also instances where Lean implementation has led to improved job satisfaction and productivity8. This ambiguity highlights the need for a deeper understanding of the socio-cultural context in which Lean practices are implemented.
Conclusion
While Lean Management offers significant benefits in terms of cost savings and efficiency improvements, it is crucial to recognize and address its potential negative side effects. Increased costs, quality issues, health and safety concerns, customer dissatisfaction, and work intensification are some of the critical challenges associated with Lean practices. Organizations must adopt a multi-perspective assessment approach to better plan and control Lean implementations, ensuring that the negative impacts are minimized and the benefits are sustained over the long term.
Sources and full results
Most relevant research papers on this topic
Negative Side Effects of Lean Management Implementations - A Causal Analysis
Negative side effects of Lean Management implementations in machine building industries can be mitigated by implementing a multi-perspective assessment method for better planning and control.
The impact of lean production on musculoskeletal and psychosocial risks: an examination of sociotechnical trends over 20 years.
Lean production can have mixed effects on occupational health and risk factors, with mixed results depending on the management style and specific implementation methods.
Systematic Review
Highly CitedLean Management Effects - An Empirical Evidence from Machine Building Industries in Europe
Lean Management implementations in machine building industries in Europe can have both planned and side effects, with this paper providing a wider understanding of these effects beyond existing literature.
The impact of lean production and related new systems of work organization on worker health.
Lean production in the auto industry may intensify work pace and demands, leading to job strain and increased musculoskeletal disorders.
Literature ReviewHighly CitedEffectiveness of combined nutrition and exercise interventions on body weight, lean mass, and fat mass in adults diagnosed with cancer: a systematic review and meta-analysis.
Combined nutrition and exercise interventions effectively reduce body weight and fat mass in adults with cancer, but also reduce lean mass, while weight loss-focused interventions are mostly associated with reduced lean mass.
Meta-AnalysisTwo faces of drug therapy in cancer: drug-related lean tissue loss and its adverse consequences to survival and toxicity
Lean tissue wasting in cancer patients is a predictor of increased treatment toxicity and reduced survival, regardless of body weight changes.
Highly CitedCan lean contribute to work intensification in healthcare?
Lean interventions in healthcare may have mixed effects, intensifying work for some and improving job satisfaction and productivity for others.
Literature ReviewThe influence of bicycle lean on maximal power output during sprint cycling.
Leaning a cycle ergometer ad libitum does not enhance maximal power output during sprint cycling, but minimizing lean impairs maximal power output by an average of 5%.
Non-RCT
Rigorous Journal