How do we solve mathematical problems and proofs?
Pro Research Analysisby 
Searched over 200M research papers
Consensus Meter
Solving Mathematical Problems and Proofs
Understanding Mathematical Proofs and Problem-Solving
Mathematical proofs are essential for explaining why certain propositions are true and why specific mathematical phenomena occur. The process of building explanations in mathematical problem-solving involves understanding the relationships between exploration, understanding, and explanation. This interactive process is crucial for developing a comprehensive understanding of mathematical concepts.
Students' Thinking Processes in Mathematical Proofs
Research on students' thinking processes in solving mathematical proof problems reveals distinct phases: entry, attack, and review. High-achieving students typically find the correct initial verification procedure and systematically complete the proof, while medium-achieving students use properties and theorems but may struggle with the final result. Low-achieving students often fail to relate properties and theorems to the verification process . This indicates that different levels of proving ability require tailored instructional strategies to enhance students' proof skills.
Heuristic Methods in Problem-Solving
George Pólya's seminal work, "How to Solve It," emphasizes heuristic methods for solving mathematical problems. Pólya's approach involves stripping away irrelevancies and focusing on the core of the problem, which can be applied to various fields beyond mathematics . His methods have been influential in teaching problem-solving techniques that are essential for developing proofs.
Contextualizing Proofs in Problem-Solving
The process of discovering proofs involves shifting perspectives, encountering wrong paths, and making mistakes. This dynamic process provides the context for continuing work on proofs and discovering the necessary reasoning. Understanding this context is vital for developing effective problem-solving strategies and improving proof skills.
Frameworks for Solving Mathematical Problems
A structured framework for solving mathematical problems involves transforming natural language descriptions into formal representations. This approach, which includes relation extraction and syntax-semantics models, has been successfully applied to solve arithmetic word problems and prove plane geometry theorems. Such frameworks highlight the importance of problem understanding and formal representation in mathematical problem-solving.
Integrating Problem-Solving and Proof Traditions
The traditions of problem-solving and proof in mathematics education are often seen as separate domains. However, both involve producing mathematical argumentation. Problem-solving emphasizes the thought processes during ongoing work, while proof focuses on evaluating the soundness of the final output. Integrating these traditions can enhance the understanding and teaching of mathematical proofs.
Improving Proof Skills with Technology
Dynamic geometry software, such as Cabri-Géomètre, has been shown to improve students' understanding of mathematical proofs. By engaging with geometric concepts and properties in a dynamic environment, students can develop better proof skills and a deeper understanding of the nature of mathematical proof.
Long-Term Development of Mathematical Thinking
The development of mathematical thinking, problem-solving, and proof is a lifelong journey. Theories on mathematical thinking emphasize the importance of developing proof skills over time, integrating knowledge and emotions, and understanding the long-term development of mathematical thinking. This holistic approach is essential for fostering a deep and enduring understanding of mathematics.
Conclusion
Solving mathematical problems and proofs involves a complex interplay of understanding, exploration, and explanation. By examining students' thinking processes, employing heuristic methods, contextualizing proofs, and integrating problem-solving and proof traditions, educators can enhance students' proof skills. Additionally, leveraging technology and understanding the long-term development of mathematical thinking are crucial for fostering a comprehensive and enduring understanding of mathematics.
Sources and full results
Most relevant research papers on this topic