How does spanking impact childhood development?
Pro Research Analysisby 
Searched over 200M research papers
Consensus Meter
The Impact of Spanking on Childhood Development
Introduction to Spanking and Child Development
Spanking, a common form of corporal punishment, has been widely used by parents globally to correct children's unwanted behaviors. However, extensive research has shown that spanking can have detrimental effects on various aspects of childhood development, including behavioral, cognitive, and socioemotional outcomes.
Behavioral Consequences of Spanking
Increased Externalizing Behaviors
Multiple studies have consistently found that spanking is associated with increased externalizing behaviors in children, such as aggression and defiance. For instance, maternal spanking at age 5 has been linked to higher levels of externalizing behavior at age 9, even after controlling for earlier child behavior and other risk factors. Similarly, spanking at ages 1 and 3 was found to be associated with higher levels of both internalizing and externalizing behaviors at age 5. These findings suggest that spanking can lead to a cycle of escalating behavioral problems over time.
Behavioral Problems in Toddlers
Research conducted in Japan using a national birth cohort data set revealed that even occasional spanking is associated with an increased number of behavioral problems in toddlers. Children who were spanked "sometimes" or "always" exhibited more behavioral issues compared to those who were never spanked. This indicates that the frequency of spanking correlates with the severity of behavioral problems.
Cognitive Development and Spanking
Impaired Cognitive Skills
Spanking has also been shown to negatively impact cognitive development. A longitudinal study found that high-frequency spanking by fathers at age 5 was associated with lower receptive vocabulary scores at age 9. This suggests that spanking can have long-term adverse effects on children's cognitive abilities.
Socioemotional Development and Spanking
Lower Socioemotional Development
Spanking has been linked to poorer socioemotional development in children. A large international study involving data from 62 countries found that spanking was associated with lower scores on a socioemotional development index among 3- and 4-year-old children. This negative relationship was consistent across 95% of the countries studied, indicating that the harmful effects of spanking on socioemotional development are widespread.
Reductions in Social-Emotional Skills
A study focusing on Bhutanese children found that spanking predicted reductions in social-emotional skills, even after controlling for various confounders. These findings reinforce the argument that spanking can hinder the development of essential social-emotional competencies in young children.
Long-Term Effects and Policy Implications
Lasting Negative Effects
The negative effects of spanking are not limited to early childhood but can extend into later stages of development. Spanking has been associated with a range of long-term issues, including poor self-esteem, impaired parent-child relationships, and increased risk of mental health problems in adulthood. Moreover, being spanked as a child has been shown to increase the likelihood of engaging in abusive behaviors as an adult.
Need for Policy and Legislative Changes
Given the mounting evidence of the harmful effects of spanking, there is a growing consensus among researchers and human rights advocates that spanking should be disavowed as a disciplinary practice. Early intervention and policy changes are critical to prevent the cascading negative effects of spanking on child development.
Conclusion
The evidence is clear: spanking is associated with a range of negative outcomes in childhood development, including increased behavioral problems, impaired cognitive skills, and poorer socioemotional development. These findings underscore the need for parents, educators, and policymakers to seek alternative, non-violent methods of child discipline to promote healthier developmental trajectories for children.
Sources and full results
Most relevant research papers on this topic