What are the challenges of promoting environmental justice and equity?

Searched over 200M research papers

Research Analysis by Consensus

Consensus Meter

Yes20%

Possibly80%

No0%

Challenges of Promoting Environmental Justice and Equity

Complex Governance and Distribution of Responsibilities

Promoting environmental justice and equity is fraught with challenges, particularly due to the complex nature of global governance and the distribution of responsibilities. The debates over who should bear the brunt of environmental and social impacts—developed versus developing countries, global versus local actors, and present versus future generations—are central to these challenges. These debates are especially pronounced in mechanisms like REDD+ under the UNFCCC, where the distribution of rights and responsibilities is highly contested.

Vague Terminology and Systemic Injustices in Planning

Environmental plans often fail to address equity and justice concerns adequately, leading to exacerbated inequities and overlooked systemic injustices. The use of vague equity terminology can hinder effective justice work. Research indicates that plans with specific and nuanced framings of equity and justice are more likely to engage comprehensively with distributive, procedural, recognition, and epistemic dimensions of justice. This highlights the need for planners to have a clear understanding of equity and justice concerns from the outset and to incorporate diverse knowledge systems, including Indigenous perspectives.

Local Autonomy and Democratic Participation

The principle of environmental equity can challenge local autonomy and democratic practices. Community protests, often labeled as NIMBYism, reflect the tension between local autonomy and broader environmental justice goals. Effective environmental justice requires not only fair distribution of environmental burdens but also democratic participation in decision-making processes that affect the production of these burdens. This necessitates a shift from merely mapping the distribution of burdens to understanding the power dynamics between local communities and the structures that produce these burdens.

Indigenous Struggles and Capabilities-Based Approach

Indigenous communities often face unique environmental justice challenges that encompass a broad range of capabilities and basic functionings. These challenges highlight the importance of cultural recognition and political participation. A capabilities-based approach to environmental justice, which focuses on the social and cultural reproduction of communities, can provide a more comprehensive understanding of these struggles. Case studies from the US and Chile illustrate how indigenous environmental justice struggles articulate themes of community capabilities and functioning.

Data Accessibility and Policy Implementation

A significant barrier to promoting environmental justice is the lack of accessible data and effective plan evaluation. Policies often focus on preventing adverse exposures rather than correcting historical inequalities. Moreover, while many policies address vulnerable populations, few specifically tackle issues of race or racism. This indicates that environmental justice has been operationalized primarily as health equity, leaving room for policy innovation in areas such as language justice and support for formerly incarcerated individuals.

Public Engagement and Framing Equity

Environmental justice activists face the challenge of framing equity in ways that are compelling to the general public. Successful efforts to reframe debates about equity can capture public attention and commitment, despite resistance to redistributive policies. This involves highlighting the connections between social and environmental justice and addressing the structural causes of prejudice. A justice-informed environmental politics must balance social justice objectives with environmental sustainability goals, extending beyond mere distribution to include recognition and participation .

Conclusion

Promoting environmental justice and equity involves navigating complex governance structures, addressing vague and systemic injustices in planning, ensuring democratic participation, recognizing indigenous struggles, overcoming data accessibility barriers, and effectively engaging the public. By addressing these challenges, we can work towards a more just and equitable environmental future.