What is the effect of decriminalization of drugs?

Searched over 200M research papers

Research Analysis by Consensus

Consensus Meter

Yes

Possibly

The Effect of Decriminalization of Drugs

Introduction to Drug Decriminalization

Drug decriminalization involves reducing or eliminating criminal penalties for drug possession and use, shifting the focus from criminal justice to public health. This approach has been implemented in various countries with the aim of reducing the negative consequences associated with drug use and the criminalization of users.

Impact on Drug Use and Availability

Prevalence and Frequency of Drug Use

Research indicates that decriminalization does not significantly impact the prevalence or frequency of drug use. Studies from the USA, which primarily focus on cannabis reform, show that legal changes are often not associated with changes in drug use metrics. Similarly, the decriminalization of marijuana in eleven states did not significantly affect self-reported drug usage, suggesting that the demand for drugs is highly inelastic with respect to changes in legal sanctions.

Age of Onset and Drug Prices

The age of onset of drug use and drug prices also appear to remain unaffected by decriminalization. A review of literature from 2016 to 2017 found no effect on the age of onset of drug use, and drug prices did not decrease following decriminalization. This is further supported by an empirical assessment of Portugal's decriminalization policy, which found no significant decrease in the prices of opiates and cocaine post-policy change.

Health and Social Harms

Public Health Approach

Decriminalization is often advocated as a means to treat drug addiction as a health disorder rather than a criminal issue. This approach is endorsed by the United Nations, which views drug addiction as preventable and treatable. Evidence from Portugal, which decriminalized all illicit drugs in 2001, indicates reductions in problematic drug use, drug-related harms, and criminal justice overcrowding.

Crime and Violence

Decriminalization can also reduce the health damage from crime and violence. Countries like Portugal, Switzerland, and the Netherlands, which have decriminalized drug use and possession, have seen positive impacts on health by reducing crime levels and associated harms. This innovative approach to healthcare management emphasizes harm reduction and public health over punitive measures.

Economic and Criminal Justice Implications

Savings in Criminal Justice System

Decriminalization measures can result in substantial savings for the criminal justice system. For instance, the decriminalization of marijuana in certain U.S. states led to significant reductions in criminal justice expenditures without discernible impacts on healthcare systems. This shift allows resources to be reallocated to more effective public health interventions.

Harm Reduction

A central feature of decriminalization is harm reduction, which aims to minimize the negative health and social consequences of drug use. This approach includes measures such as fines instead of prison terms and avoiding permanent criminal records for drug users. By reducing the penalties associated with drug use, decriminalization can help mitigate the harms perpetuated by the criminal underworld and reduce the stigma associated with drug use.

Conclusion

The decriminalization of drugs presents a complex but potentially beneficial shift from punitive measures to a public health-oriented approach. While it does not significantly impact drug use prevalence, age of onset, or drug prices, it offers substantial benefits in terms of reducing health and social harms, crime, and criminal justice costs. Countries that have implemented decriminalization policies, such as Portugal, provide valuable insights into the positive outcomes of this approach. However, further research is needed to fully understand and optimize the impacts of drug decriminalization on society.