What are the ethical considerations in the use of digital surveillance for public health and safety?
Pro Research Analysisby 
Searched over 200M research papers
Consensus Meter
Ethical Considerations in the Use of Digital Surveillance for Public Health and Safety
Privacy and Confidentiality in Digital Surveillance
One of the primary ethical concerns in the use of digital surveillance for public health is the protection of privacy and confidentiality. Digital surveillance systems, especially those augmented with artificial intelligence, often collect highly sensitive data, such as individuals' movements and contacts. This data can be exposed to outside sources, significantly impinging upon basic human and civil rights . The use of passive data, collected without active user participation, further complicates the issue, as it raises questions about informed consent and the extent to which individuals are aware of and agree to the surveillance.
Trust and Public Participation
Trust is a critical factor in the successful implementation of digital surveillance systems. Public trust and participation in these systems can be unevenly distributed across society, with marginalized groups often expressing greater mistrust. This mistrust can stem from historical legacies of harm and the perception that the state's motives are self-interested rather than welfare-oriented . Establishing trustworthiness through transparent governance frameworks and interpersonal interactions with public health personnel is essential to reversing these legacies and ensuring equitable participation.
Governance and Ethical Frameworks
The governance of digital surveillance systems is another significant ethical consideration. The rapid deployment of these technologies during the COVID-19 pandemic highlighted the lag in ethical governance compared to technological advancements. Clear governance frameworks are necessary to address public concerns about privacy protection, data integrity, and autonomy . Ethical frameworks should also consider the promotion of justice and the need for interdisciplinary capacity building among research ethics committees.
Equity and Digital Divides
Digital surveillance systems have the potential to widen existing healthcare disparities and digital divides. Vulnerable and at-risk populations may be underrepresented in these systems, leading to biased data and unequal access to public health interventions . Addressing these disparities requires a nuanced, context-sensitive approach to surveillance that empowers stakeholders to participate in the design and implementation of data infrastructure and governance.
Ethical Use of Big Data and New Technologies
The use of big data and new technologies in public health surveillance presents both opportunities and ethical challenges. While these technologies can provide more accurate and timely warnings of infectious disease outbreaks, they also raise concerns about the ethical use of personal health data. Public health authorities must balance the benefits of these technologies with the need for informed public discussion, greater transparency, and an ethical framework to build public trust.
Conclusion
The ethical considerations in the use of digital surveillance for public health and safety are multifaceted and complex. Key issues include privacy and confidentiality, trust and public participation, governance and ethical frameworks, equity and digital divides, and the ethical use of big data and new technologies. Addressing these concerns requires a comprehensive and transparent approach that involves all stakeholders and prioritizes the protection of individual rights and the promotion of public trust.
Sources and full results
Most relevant research papers on this topic