What policy evaluations and modeling is needed for deductible in health insurance
Pro Research Analysisby 
Searched over 200M research papers
Consensus Meter
Policy Evaluations and Modeling for Deductibles in Health Insurance
Introduction to Deductibles in Health Insurance
Deductibles in health insurance are a common feature designed to share the cost of healthcare between insurers and policyholders. They require the insured to pay a certain amount out-of-pocket before the insurance coverage kicks in. This article synthesizes research on the policy evaluations and modeling needed for implementing deductibles in health insurance.
Demand for Deductibles: Influencing Factors
Socio-Economic Characteristics and Health Status
The decision to opt for a health insurance policy with a deductible is influenced by various socio-economic factors such as age, income, education, and family size, as well as health status and medical consumption. A study analyzing 8000 privately insured families found that health, medical consumption, and income significantly impact the choice of insurance type, indicating potential adverse selection if deductibles are offered.
Impact on Health Care Utilization and Costs
High-deductible health plans (HDHPs) have been shown to reduce healthcare costs and utilization, including necessary preventive services. A systematic review revealed that HDHPs are associated with a significant reduction in preventive care and office visits, which can lead to decreased appropriate and inappropriate care. This suggests that while HDHPs can lower costs, they may also deter necessary medical care.
Evaluating the Introduction of Deductibles
Public Decision-Making and Regulated Competition
Introducing deductibles in social health systems can create a regulated competition among insurers and providers. This approach modifies co-payment rules and affects the prices paid by patients. Evaluations must consider the elasticity of demand, as price increases can reduce demand, impacting the public budget and different citizen groups.
Dynamic Consumer Behavior Models
Theoretical models of consumer behavior under variable price schedules, such as those with cumulative deductibles, show that the perceived price of care decreases as the consumer approaches the deductible. This model suggests that deductibles above a certain range are not optimal as they add risk without return. Demand analysis should focus on episodes of illness rather than annual medical demand to avoid biased estimates.
Actuarial Modeling and Out-of-Pocket Costs
Estimating Health Expenses and Reimbursements
Actuarial techniques are essential for estimating total health expenses, out-of-pocket costs, and reimbursements under health insurance schemes with deductibles and stop-loss provisions. The Pitacco model, which incorporates both deductible and stop-loss parameters, demonstrates a positive relationship between total health expenses and the share funded by out-of-pocket spending.
Deductible Ratemaking Approaches
Two primary approaches to deductible ratemaking are the regression approach and the maximum likelihood approach. The regression approach is advantageous for predicting aggregate claims, while the maximum likelihood approach is better for calculating theoretically correct relativities for deductible levels. Combining models for specific peril types can improve ratemaking accuracy.
Conclusion
Evaluating and modeling deductibles in health insurance requires a comprehensive understanding of socio-economic factors, consumer behavior, and actuarial techniques. Policymakers must carefully consider the impact on healthcare utilization, costs, and public budgets to design optimal insurance policies that balance cost-sharing and access to necessary medical care.
Sources and full results
Most relevant research papers on this topic