Will protein drinks make you fat
Pro Research Analysisby 
Searched over 200M research papers
Do Protein Drinks Make You Gain Weight?
Protein Drinks and Energy Intake
Protein drinks, particularly those rich in whey protein, are often used to manage malnutrition and support muscle growth. However, their impact on overall energy intake and weight gain is complex. Studies have shown that consuming protein drinks can increase total energy intake when combined with meals. For instance, older men who consumed whey protein drinks did not experience a suppression in appetite or energy intake compared to a control group, leading to an overall increase in energy intake . This suggests that protein drinks can contribute to a higher caloric intake, which may lead to weight gain if not balanced with physical activity.
Macronutrient Composition and Weight Gain
The composition of protein drinks also plays a significant role in their effects on weight. Drinks that combine protein with carbohydrates and fats tend to have different impacts on gastric emptying and hormone responses. For example, adding carbohydrates and fats to whey protein can accelerate gastric emptying and reduce the suppression of hunger hormones like ghrelin, potentially leading to increased food intake. This combination can result in a higher total caloric intake, which may contribute to weight gain if not offset by increased energy expenditure.
Protein Drinks and Muscle Mass
Protein drinks are beneficial for increasing muscle mass, especially when combined with resistance training. A study on older adults showed that consuming a high-protein dairy milk beverage, along with progressive resistance training, significantly increased fat-free mass and muscle strength. This increase in muscle mass can contribute to a higher metabolic rate, which may help in managing body weight. However, without adequate physical activity, the additional calories from protein drinks could still lead to weight gain.
Protein Drinks and Fat Oxidation
The type of protein consumed can also influence fat oxidation and overall metabolism. Post-exercise protein intake has been shown to double whole-body fat oxidation during subsequent exercise sessions, although this effect is less pronounced with carbohydrate intake. This indicates that protein drinks can support fat metabolism, which might help in weight management. However, the overall impact on body weight will depend on the balance between caloric intake and expenditure.
Conclusion
In summary, protein drinks can contribute to weight gain if they lead to an increase in total caloric intake that is not balanced by physical activity. The macronutrient composition of these drinks and their combination with exercise play crucial roles in determining their impact on body weight. While protein drinks can support muscle growth and fat oxidation, their potential to cause weight gain should be considered, especially in the context of overall diet and lifestyle.
Sources and full results
Most relevant research papers on this topic