Is working from home better or worse than working in office?

Searched over 200M research papers

Research Analysis by Consensus

Consensus Meter

Yes

Possibly

Is Working from Home Better or Worse than Working in the Office?

Performance and Productivity: Work from Home vs. Office

Increased Productivity in Work from Home Settings

Several studies have shown that working from home (WFH) can lead to increased productivity. For instance, an experiment at Ctrip, a Chinese travel agency, revealed a 13% performance increase among employees working from home. This boost was attributed to fewer breaks, fewer sick days, and a quieter working environment, which allowed employees to make more calls per minute . Similarly, a systematic review found that non-mandatory WFH arrangements generally led to higher productivity and performance.

Mixed Results During the Pandemic

However, the impact of WFH during the COVID-19 pandemic has been mixed. While some employees reported increased efficiency, others experienced a decline in productivity due to distractions and lack of proper work equipment . A review of literature during the pandemic showed that only 23% of studies reported positive effects on productivity, while 38% showed mixed results, and another 38% indicated negative effects.

Employee Satisfaction and Well-being

Improved Job Satisfaction and Reduced Attrition

WFH has been associated with higher job satisfaction and lower attrition rates. The Ctrip experiment noted that employees working from home reported improved work satisfaction and a 50% reduction in attrition rates . Another study found that hybrid WFH arrangements reduced attrition rates by 35% and improved self-reported work satisfaction scores.

Well-being and Work-life Balance

The flexibility of WFH has also positively impacted employees' well-being and work-life balance. A survey of academics found that 70% believed they would be similarly or more efficient if they could spend more time working from home in the future. Additionally, 66% preferred to work more from home to improve their well-being. However, the lack of social interaction and proper work equipment were noted as significant challenges .

Challenges and Drawbacks

Communication and Collaboration Issues

One of the main drawbacks of WFH is the difficulty in maintaining effective communication and collaboration. Employees working from home reported feeling isolated and found it challenging to share thoughts and keep in touch with their teams . A study involving European countries found that co-workers working from home negatively impacted individual and team performance, highlighting the importance of in-person interactions for effective teamwork.

Promotion and Career Advancement

Another concern is the impact of WFH on career advancement. The Ctrip experiment showed that while WFH employees had higher performance, their promotion rates were lower compared to their in-office counterparts . This suggests that visibility and networking opportunities in the office may play a crucial role in career progression.

The Future of Work: Hybrid Models

Hybrid Work as a Balanced Approach

Given the mixed results, many researchers advocate for a hybrid work model that combines the benefits of both WFH and office work. This approach allows employees to enjoy the flexibility and comfort of working from home while maintaining the social and collaborative advantages of the office . Implementing hybrid work models requires careful planning, creativity, and trust from both employers and employees to maximize the benefits.

Design and Policy Considerations

To support hybrid work, organizations need to invest in proper home office setups and ensure that employees have access to necessary equipment and resources. Additionally, policies should be aligned with business goals to foster a resilient and inclusive work environment .

Conclusion

In summary, working from home offers several benefits, including increased productivity, improved job satisfaction, and better work-life balance. However, it also presents challenges such as communication issues, potential isolation, and impacts on career advancement. A hybrid work model that combines the advantages of both WFH and office work appears to be the optimal solution for the future, requiring thoughtful implementation and support from organizations.