Bone broth and collagen
Pro Research Analysisby 
Searched over 200M research papers
Bone Broth and Collagen: Analyzing Nutritional Efficacy
Bone Broth Amino Acid Content
Variability in Amino Acid Concentrations
Bone broth (BB) is often touted for its potential health benefits, particularly its collagen content. However, recent research indicates that the amino acid concentrations in bone broth can be highly variable. A study analyzing both commercial and laboratory-prepared bone broth found significant differences in the levels of key amino acids such as glycine, lysine, proline, leucine, hydroxyproline, and hydroxylysine. Standardized recipes yielded lower concentrations of these amino acids compared to collagen supplements, and nonstandardized recipes showed even greater variability, with the highest levels found in café-prepared varieties1.
Comparison with Collagen Supplements
When compared to collagen supplements, bone broth falls short in providing a consistent and reliable source of collagen precursors. The study highlighted that even the best-prepared bone broths could not match the amino acid concentrations found in a therapeutic dose of collagen supplements. This suggests that for those looking to increase their intake of collagen precursors, supplements may be a more effective and reliable option1.
Collagen Extraction and Concentration
Hydrothermal Treatment and Protein Content
Another study focused on the production of collagen-containing broths during gelatin production. The research examined how the duration of hydrothermal treatment affects the concentration of proteins in the broth. It was found that longer treatment times (up to 180 minutes) significantly increased the dry matter content and protein concentration in the broths. The protein content in the dry concentrate ranged from 64.19% to 82.89%, depending on the duration of the treatment2.
Spray Drying and Gelling Capacity
The study also explored the process of spray drying to obtain dry protein concentrates from the collagen broth. The resulting dry concentrates exhibited high gelling capacity and were found to be homogeneous powders ranging in color from white to light cream. This method of processing could potentially offer a more concentrated and stable form of collagen, which might be beneficial for various applications2.
Conclusion
While bone broth is often promoted for its collagen content, research indicates that its amino acid concentrations are inconsistent and generally lower than those found in collagen supplements. For those seeking to boost their collagen intake, supplements may offer a more reliable source. Additionally, advanced processing methods like hydrothermal treatment and spray drying can enhance the protein content and stability of collagen products, potentially offering more effective alternatives to traditional bone broth.
Sources and full results
Most relevant research papers on this topic
Bone Broth Unlikely to Provide Reliable Concentrations of Collagen Precursors Compared With Supplemental Sources of Collagen Used in Collagen Research.
Bone broth is unlikely to provide a consistently reliable source of key amino acids needed for collagen synthesis, compared to collagen supplements.
Obtaining dry protein concentrates from secondary gelatin products
The duration of hydrothermal treatment of collagen raw materials affects the concentration of high-protein broths, with gelation time reducing as treatment time increases.
Bone Collagen Quality Indicators for Palaeodietary and Radiocarbon Measurements
Bone collagen quality indicators can identify many cases of contamination, but cannot detect natural levels of contamination.
Highly CitedThe Use of Collagen-Based Materials in Bone Tissue Engineering
Collagen-based materials show promise for bone regeneration, but improvements in mechanical properties, degradation, and osteoconductive activity are needed for efficient clinical application.
Identification and antioxidant activity of bovine bone collagen-derived novel peptides prepared by recombinant collagenase from Bacillus cereus.
Recombinant collagenase from Bacillus cereus effectively hydrolyzes bovine bone collagen to collagen-soluble peptides, which show promising antioxidant activity and potential for functional food applications.
Analysis of collagen from normal and abnormal human bone.
The type of collagen in human bone remains the same in both normal and abnormal samples, suggesting that the collagen type in bone is not altered in bone diseases studied.
In Vitro StudyCollagen for bone tissue regeneration.
Innovative techniques for collagen-based scaffold and material manufacturing are leading to improved bone tissue regeneration and tissue engineering applications.
Highly CitedA Comparative Study on Quality and Physicochemical Characteristics of Segmental Bone Korean Beef Broth
Optimizing Korean beef main bone recipes requires comparing the quality and physiochemical properties of beef leg bone, beef feet, and tail broth, with a focus on protein, fat, and moisture.
Collagen Type I Biomaterials as Scaffolds for Bone Tissue Engineering
Collagen type I biomaterials show promise for bone tissue engineering, but improvements are needed to address biodegradability, mechanical strength, and osteoinductive activity.
Highly CitedEffect of dietary supplementation with collagen hydrolysates on bone metabolism of postmenopausal women with low mineral density.
Dietary supplementation with collagen hydrolysates did not significantly affect bone metabolism in postmenopausal women with low bone mineral density.
RCT