Breathing exercises for panic attacks
Pro Research Analysisby 
Searched over 200M research papers
Breathing Exercises for Panic Attacks: Efficacy and Insights
Introduction to Breathing Exercises for Panic Attacks
Breathing exercises are often recommended as a self-help tool for managing panic attacks. These exercises aim to regulate breathing patterns, reduce anxiety, and restore a sense of calm. However, the effectiveness of these techniques has been a subject of debate among researchers.
Efficacy of Breathing Training (BT) in Panic Disorder
Mixed Results in Clinical Studies
Several studies have explored the efficacy of breathing training (BT) for treating panic disorder, with mixed results. Some research indicates that BT can reduce the frequency and intensity of panic attacks by addressing hyperventilation and respiratory irregularities 146. However, other studies suggest that the benefits of BT may not be specific to hyperventilators and could be attributed to non-specific effects such as altered beliefs and expectancies, exposure to bodily sensations, and attention to regular and slow breathing 23.
Physiological and Psychological Outcomes
Research has shown that both methods of breathing training—raising and lowering end-tidal CO2—can effectively reduce the severity of panic disorder. These improvements were maintained at a six-month follow-up, indicating that patients had learned to alter their CO2 levels and respiration rates as taught in therapy . This suggests that the clinical improvement may depend on common elements in both breathing therapies rather than the specific effect on CO2 levels.
Mechanisms Behind Breathing Exercises
Hyperventilation and Panic Attacks
Hyperventilation has been identified as a potential trigger for panic attacks. Breathing retraining aims to correct hyperventilation by teaching patients to control their breathing patterns, which can reduce the frequency of panic attacks 467. However, some researchers argue that hyperventilation plays a limited role in producing panic attacks, suggesting that breathing retraining may only be useful for a subset of patients .
False Suffocation Alarm Theory
An opposing theory, known as the false suffocation alarm theory, suggests that panic attacks may be triggered by a misinterpretation of suffocation signals. This theory implies that different breathing techniques, such as raising end-tidal CO2, could be beneficial . The effectiveness of both raising and lowering CO2 levels in reducing panic symptoms supports the idea that the therapeutic benefits may stem from common elements in the breathing exercises rather than the specific technique used.
Practical Applications and Considerations
Self-Help Management
Breathing exercises are a powerful and straightforward tool for self-help management during panic attacks. These techniques can be used anywhere to reduce anxiety, lower stress levels, and force the body to relax, thereby deconditioning panic attacks and restoring homeostasis .
Limitations and Caveats
Despite the potential benefits, there are concerns about the routine use of breathing retraining. Some studies suggest that it may prevent patients from learning that their catastrophic beliefs are unfounded, potentially leading to poorer outcomes when combined with other cognitive-behavioral treatments 910. Therefore, clinicians must exercise care to ensure that breathing retraining is not misused as a means of escaping or avoiding feared sensations.
Conclusion
Breathing exercises can be an effective tool for managing panic attacks, particularly by addressing hyperventilation and altering respiratory patterns. However, the benefits may not be specific to hyperventilators and could be due to common therapeutic elements. While breathing retraining can play a useful role in treating panic disorder, it is essential to consider its limitations and ensure it is used appropriately within a broader therapeutic context. Further research is needed to refine these techniques and better understand their mechanisms and efficacy.
Sources and full results
Most relevant research papers on this topic