Breathing techniques for panic attacks
Pro Research Analysisby 
Searched over 200M research papers
Breathing Techniques for Panic Attacks
Introduction to Breathing Techniques for Panic Disorder
Panic disorder is characterized by recurrent and unexpected panic attacks, which can be debilitating for those affected. Breathing techniques have been explored as a potential intervention to manage and reduce the symptoms of panic attacks. This article synthesizes findings from multiple studies to provide an overview of the efficacy and mechanisms of various breathing techniques in treating panic disorder.
Efficacy of Breathing Training (BT) in Panic Disorder
Breathing training (BT) is a common therapeutic approach for panic disorder, focusing on regulating respiration to manage symptoms. However, the overall efficacy of BT remains inconclusive. Some studies suggest that BT can reduce the frequency and intensity of panic attacks, but the evidence is not robust enough to make definitive claims1. The effectiveness of BT may depend on factors such as the specific techniques used and the physiological monitoring of respiration rates and tidal volumes during therapy1.
Controlled Breathing and Anxiety Reduction
Controlled breathing techniques have shown some promise in reducing anxiety associated with panic attacks. In a study comparing controlled breathing to a placebo treatment, patients who received breathing training exhibited greater improvements in observer-rated anxiety, although self-reported measures did not show significant differences2. This suggests that controlled breathing may have a non-specific calming effect, beneficial for patients with panic attacks regardless of their hyperventilation status2.
Opposing Breathing Therapies: Raising vs. Lowering CO2 Levels
A randomized controlled trial investigated two opposing breathing therapies: one aimed at raising end-tidal CO2 levels to counteract hyperventilation, and the other aimed at lowering CO2 levels. Both methods were effective in reducing the severity of panic disorder, with sustained effects observed at six-month follow-up3. The study concluded that the clinical improvements were likely due to common elements in both therapies, such as altered beliefs, exposure to bodily sensations, and attention to regular, slow breathing3.
Hyperventilation and Respiratory Control
Hyperventilation has been identified as a central factor in panic attacks, and respiratory control techniques have been developed to address this issue. Training patients to control their breathing patterns, including reducing breath-to-breath irregularity and chest breathing, has been shown to reduce panic symptoms4 5. These techniques often involve biofeedback to help patients gain voluntary control over their respiration8.
Self-Help Breathing Exercises
Breathing exercises are a straightforward and powerful tool for self-help management during panic attacks. These exercises can be performed anywhere and help reduce anxiety, lower stress levels, and promote relaxation7. By focusing on slow, deep breathing, individuals can decondition their panic responses and restore physiological balance7.
Cognitive-Behavioral Therapy (CBT) and Breathing Retraining
The role of breathing retraining within cognitive-behavioral therapy (CBT) for panic disorder has been questioned. Some studies suggest that adding breathing retraining to CBT does not provide additional benefits and may even result in poorer outcomes for some patients9. This indicates that while breathing techniques can be helpful, they may not be necessary when other effective CBT interventions are in place9.
Cold Facial Immersion (CFI) and Panic Symptoms
An innovative approach to managing panic symptoms involves cold facial immersion (CFI). This technique, which triggers the diving response, has been shown to reduce both physiological and cognitive symptoms of panic in patients with panic disorder10. CFI significantly lowers heart rate and lessens self-reported anxiety, demonstrating its potential as a clinical tool for panic management10.
Conclusion
Breathing techniques offer a range of benefits for managing panic attacks, from reducing anxiety to altering physiological responses. While the evidence is mixed regarding the specific efficacy of different breathing methods, common elements such as regular, slow breathing and altered beliefs about bodily sensations appear to be beneficial. Further research is needed to refine these techniques and integrate them effectively into comprehensive treatment plans for panic disorder.
Sources and full results
Most relevant research papers on this topic
Breathing Training for Treating Panic Disorder
Breathing training (BT) for panic disorder shows mixed results, with more research needed to confirm its effectiveness and compare it to cognitive or other interventions.
Systematic Review
Highly CitedRespiratory Control: Its Contribution to the Treatment of Panic Attacks
Training in controlled breathing may have a non-specific effect in treating panic attacks, with no specific benefit for those identified as 'hyperventilators' by the provocation test.
RCTOpposing breathing therapies for panic disorder: a randomized controlled trial of lowering vs raising end-tidal P(CO₂).
Both raising and lowering end-tidal CO2 levels effectively reduce panic disorder severity, with clinical improvement likely based on elements common to both therapies.
RCTThe efficacy of breathing retraining and the centrality of hyperventilation in panic disorder: a reinterpretation of experimental findings.
Breathing retraining significantly reduces the frequency of panic attacks and supports the central role of hyperventilation in primary panic attacks.
Respiratory control as a treatment for panic attacks.
Respiratory control treatment significantly reduces panic attack frequency and self-reported fear after 2 weeks, with further reductions at 6-month and 2-year follow-up.
Non-RCTHighly CitedA case of panic disorder treated with breathing retraining.
Breathing retraining can effectively reduce the frequency and intensity of panic attacks in patients with panic disorder.
Case ReportBreathing Exercise - A Commanding Tool for Self-help Management during Panic attacks
Breathing exercises can help patients manage panic attacks by reducing anxiety, lowering stress levels, and promoting relaxation, thereby restoring hemostasis.
Respiratory feedback for treating panic disorder.
Respiratory biofeedback can help patients with panic disorder modify breathing patterns, reducing symptoms and providing valuable diagnostic, prognostic, and outcome information.
Dismantling cognitive-behavioral treatment for panic disorder: questioning the utility of breathing retraining.
Breathing retraining in cognitive-behavioral treatment for panic disorder may not provide additional benefits compared to other interventions.
RCTHighly CitedThe Implications of the Diving Response in Reducing Panic Symptoms
Cold facial immersion significantly reduces panic symptoms in patients with panic disorder by reducing heart rate and self-reported anxiety and panic.
RCT