Carbon cost
Pro Research Analysisby 
Searched over 200M research papers for "carbon cost"
Understanding the Social Cost of Carbon: Key Insights and Implications
Introduction to the Social Cost of Carbon (SCC)
The Social Cost of Carbon (SCC) is a critical metric in climate change economics, representing the economic cost of the damages caused by emitting one additional ton of carbon dioxide (CO2) into the atmosphere. This value is used to inform and shape climate policies by monetizing the incremental impact of carbon emissions on socioeconomic systems .
Estimation Models and Variability in SCC
Integrated Assessment Models (IAMs)
Integrated Assessment Models (IAMs) are commonly used to estimate the SCC. These models integrate data from various disciplines, including economics and climate science, to assess the long-term impacts of carbon emissions. Research indicates that IAMs have been widely used since the 1990s, with notable models including DICE (Dynamic Integrated model of Climate and the Economy), RICE, and PAGE . The DICE model, for instance, has been updated to provide more accurate estimates, with the SCC estimated at $31 per ton of CO2 for the year 2015.
Range of Estimates
The estimated SCC varies significantly across studies, reflecting differences in model assumptions, discount rates, and climate sensitivity. For example, estimates range from as low as -$50 to as high as $8,752 per ton of carbon (tC), with a mean value of approximately $200.57/tC ($54.70/tCO2). Another study using the DICE-2013R model estimated the SCC at $18.6 per ton of CO2 in 2005 US dollars, growing at 3% per year until 2050. These variations highlight the complexity and uncertainty inherent in calculating the SCC.
Factors Influencing SCC Estimates
Discount Rates and Time Preference
The choice of discount rate significantly impacts SCC estimates. A higher pure rate of time preference (PRTP) generally results in a lower SCC, as future damages are discounted more heavily . For instance, using a PRTP of 0.1% per year, as in the Stern Review, increases the mean SCC to $365 per ton.
Climate Sensitivity and Economic Parameters
Climate sensitivity, which measures the temperature response to a doubling of CO2 concentrations, also plays a crucial role. Higher climate sensitivity leads to higher SCC estimates due to greater anticipated damages . Additionally, economic parameters such as the rate of risk aversion and assumptions about future economic growth and technological advancements contribute to the variability in SCC estimates.
Country-Level and Long-Term Considerations
Regional Disparities
Global estimates of the SCC can obscure significant regional differences in climate impacts and economic damages. Recent studies have attempted to estimate country-level SCC, revealing that countries like India, China, Saudi Arabia, and the United States bear large fractions of the global cost. This regional approach underscores the importance of considering geographic heterogeneity in climate policy.
Ultimate Cost of Carbon
Some studies extend the analysis to a much longer time horizon, estimating the "ultimate cost of carbon" over a million-year scale. These estimates range from $10,000 to $750,000 per ton of carbon, reflecting the potential long-term economic impacts of fossil fuel use on future generations.
Alternative Approaches and Policy Implications
Near-Term to Net Zero (NT2NZ) Approach
Given the wide range of SCC estimates, some researchers advocate for alternative approaches to setting carbon prices. The Near-Term to Net Zero (NT2NZ) approach focuses on the CO2 prices needed to achieve net-zero emissions targets by specific dates, such as 2050. This method provides more practical guidance for policymakers by aligning carbon pricing with emission reduction goals and complementary policies.
Policy Recommendations
To enhance the utility of the SCC in policy-making, it is crucial to address key issues such as the appropriate discount rate, potential for catastrophic damages, and the harmonization of abatement policies. Additionally, advances in attribution science and econometric techniques can improve the accuracy of SCC estimates by better quantifying the economic impacts of extreme weather events and other climate-related damages.
Conclusion
The Social Cost of Carbon is a vital tool for understanding and mitigating the economic impacts of climate change. While estimates vary widely due to differences in models, assumptions, and parameters, the SCC remains central to climate policy. By refining estimation methods and considering alternative approaches like NT2NZ, policymakers can better navigate the complexities of carbon pricing and implement effective climate strategies.
Sources and full results
Most relevant research papers on this topic