Cimetidine vs omeprazole efficacy
Pro Research Analysisby 
Searched over 200M research papers
Duodenal Ulcer Healing: Omeprazole vs. Cimetidine Efficacy
Multiple studies have compared omeprazole and cimetidine for duodenal ulcer healing. Omeprazole consistently shows faster and higher healing rates than cimetidine. After two weeks, healing rates with omeprazole ranged from 58% to 73%, while cimetidine ranged from 44% to 46% 1235. At four weeks, omeprazole achieved healing rates of 84% to 97%, compared to 74% to 89% for cimetidine 1235. These differences were statistically significant in several studies, especially at earlier time points 235. Omeprazole was also more effective for healing large ulcers, where cimetidine’s efficacy was notably lower .
Pain Relief and Symptom Resolution in Ulcer Disease
Omeprazole provides more rapid and complete pain relief than cimetidine in duodenal ulcer patients. After two weeks, a higher percentage of patients on omeprazole reported complete pain relief compared to those on cimetidine (62% vs. 46%) . Omeprazole also led to significantly fewer reports of daytime epigastric pain and more patients becoming pain-free during the first week of treatment 26. For mild or moderate daytime pain, omeprazole was superior, though there was no significant difference for nocturnal pain .
Efficacy in Gastric Ulcer and Reflux Oesophagitis
In patients with prepyloric gastric ulcers, omeprazole led to higher healing rates at two, four, and six weeks compared to cimetidine, with a significant difference at two weeks (54% vs. 39%) . For erosive reflux oesophagitis, omeprazole provided greater and more rapid symptom relief, faster and more sustained endoscopic and histological healing, and a greater reduction in acid exposure than cimetidine 47. After four weeks, omeprazole healed 56% of oesophagitis cases versus 26% for cimetidine, and by eight weeks, the rates were 71% and 35%, respectively . Omeprazole also relieved more patients’ reflux symptoms, both by day and night 4710.
Heartburn Relief in GERD
Omeprazole is more effective than cimetidine for relieving heartburn in all grades of gastro-oesophageal reflux disease (GERD), regardless of whether endoscopic oesophagitis is present . This advantage extends to patients with reflux symptoms but no visible oesophagitis, a group often excluded from earlier studies .
Upper Gastrointestinal Bleeding and Stress Ulcer Prophylaxis
For upper gastrointestinal bleeding from peptic sources, omeprazole and cimetidine showed similar efficacy in terms of mortality, surgical requirements, transfusion needs, and hospital stay . However, in patients with intracerebral hemorrhage at risk for stress-related upper GI bleeding, omeprazole significantly reduced the incidence of bleeding compared to cimetidine (15.5% vs. 27.8%) . High-dose omeprazole was also effective in arresting active bleeding .
Safety and Adverse Events
Both omeprazole and cimetidine were generally well tolerated, with no major clinical or biochemical side effects reported in the studies 12356. The incidence of adverse events was low and similar between the two drugs .
Conclusion
Omeprazole is generally more effective than cimetidine for healing duodenal and gastric ulcers, providing faster and more complete pain relief, and achieving higher healing rates in reflux oesophagitis and GERD-related heartburn. For stress ulcer prophylaxis in high-risk patients, omeprazole also offers superior protection. Both drugs are safe, but omeprazole’s greater efficacy makes it the preferred choice in most acid-related gastrointestinal conditions.
Sources and full results
Most relevant research papers on this topic