Definition of a chemical element
Pro Research Analysisby 
Searched over 200M research papers
Dual Definitions of a Chemical Element: Abstract Concept and Simple Substance
The definition of a chemical element is complex and has evolved over time. There are two main ways the term is used. First, it can mean a simple substance, like chlorine gas or solid sulfur, which are pure forms of an element. Second, it can refer to an abstract concept that groups all forms of a substance, such as all isotopes and allotropes of carbon, under one element based on their shared properties in the periodic table. This dual definition is recognized by the International Union of Pure and Applied Chemistry (IUPAC), but it can cause confusion because it mixes an operational, substance-based view with an abstract, conceptual one 1578.
Atomic Number and the Modern Scientific Definition
Scientifically, a chemical element is defined as a pure substance made up of atoms that all have the same number of protons in their nuclei. This number of protons is called the atomic number and is the key property that identifies an element. All atoms with the same atomic number are considered atoms of the same element, regardless of their isotopes or physical form. Elements cannot be broken down into simpler substances by chemical means, and they are the basic building blocks of all matter in the universe 247.
Historical Perspectives and Evolving Concepts
The concept of a chemical element has changed throughout history. Early ideas, such as those from Greek philosophers, saw elements as basic substances making up all matter. Later, chemists like Lavoisier defined elements as substances that could not be decomposed further by chemical means. Mendeleev’s work on the periodic table further refined the concept, distinguishing between simple substances (the physical form) and the element as an abstract entity defined by its position in the periodic system 6910.
Isotopes and Alternative Views
Some researchers argue that each isotope, with its unique nucleus, should be considered a separate element, which would mean the periodic table is actually a table of isotopes. However, the widely accepted view is that isotopes are different forms of the same element, as long as they share the same atomic number 34.
Educational and Philosophical Challenges
The dual and sometimes ambiguous definition of a chemical element can create confusion, especially for students. The distinction between elements as substances and as abstract categories is not always clear, and combining both meanings in one term can lead to misunderstandings. Educators and philosophers continue to debate the best way to define and teach the concept of a chemical element 1578.
Conclusion
A chemical element is most commonly defined as a substance whose atoms all have the same number of protons, known as the atomic number. This definition is central to modern chemistry and the periodic table. However, the term also carries a dual meaning, referring both to the physical substance and to an abstract concept, which has led to ongoing debates and challenges in education and philosophy.
Sources and full results
Most relevant research papers on this topic