Depression and crying spells
Pro Research Analysisby 
Searched over 200M research papers
Depression and Crying Spells: An In-Depth Analysis
Crying Threshold and Intensity in Major Depressive Disorder
Contrary to common belief, individuals with major depressive disorder (MDD) do not necessarily cry more frequently or intensely than non-depressed individuals. A study comparing the emotional and physiological responses to a cry-evoking stimulus found that depressed participants were not more likely to cry than their non-depressed counterparts. Interestingly, non-depressed individuals who cried showed significant increases in sadness and physiological activation, such as cardiac and electrodermal responses. In contrast, depressed individuals exhibited less emotional activation when they cried, suggesting a dysregulation of emotional responses in depression.
Crying as a Symptom of Depression
Despite the common association between crying and sadness, crying is not consistently listed as a symptom of depression in major psychiatric textbooks. This omission highlights the complexity and variability of depressive symptoms. While crying is often observed in individuals experiencing sadness, its role as a diagnostic criterion for depression remains controversial.
Crying Spells in Severe Depression
Crying spells are frequently reported in severe cases of depression, often accompanied by other symptoms such as loss of interest in activities, insomnia, and feelings of hopelessness. For instance, an elderly woman with severe depression exhibited crying spells along with other depressive symptoms, indicating that crying can be a significant manifestation of severe depressive episodes.
Pseudobulbar Affect and Depression
Pseudobulbar affect (PBA), characterized by involuntary crying or laughing, can be mistaken for depression due to its emotional outbursts. A case study of a stroke patient initially misdiagnosed with depression due to crying spells revealed that proper treatment for PBA, rather than depression, resolved the crying episodes. This underscores the importance of accurate diagnosis and treatment, as misdiagnosis can lead to ineffective management of symptoms.
Mood Disorders and Crying Behavior
Mood disorders, including depression, can alter crying behavior. Patients with mood disorders report increased crying in response to negative stimuli and less mood improvement after crying compared to non-depressed individuals. Notably, male patients with severe depression show a higher frequency of crying, suggesting that mood disorders may influence crying behavior differently across genders.
Post-Stroke Pathological Crying
Pathological crying, often seen in post-stroke patients, is characterized by uncontrollable crying episodes that are disproportionate to the individual's emotional state. This condition, known as pathological laughing and crying (PLC), is common among stroke survivors and can be effectively treated with antidepressants, particularly SSRIs. However, it is crucial to distinguish PLC from depression, as the treatment and underlying mechanisms differ.
Crying in Hospitalized Patients
In a study of hospitalized patients referred for psychiatric consultation due to crying, a significant portion was found to have neurological disorders, psychiatric disorders, or both. The most common psychiatric disorder was major depression, while neurological disorders often involved bilateral hemispheric dysfunction. Proper identification of the underlying cause of crying is essential for effective treatment.
Gender Differences in Crying and Depression
The Center for Epidemiologic Studies' Depression Scale (CES-D) reveals gender differences in the association between crying and depression. While crying spells are a strong indicator of depressed mood in women, they do not serve the same diagnostic purpose for men. This suggests that depressive symptoms and their manifestations can vary significantly between genders.
Maternal Depression and Infant Crying
Maternal depression is closely linked to excessive infant crying (EC). Studies indicate that concurrent and subsequent maternal depression is robustly associated with EC, whereas preceding maternal depression is not. This relationship suggests that maternal depression may be a consequence of EC rather than a cause. Conversely, maternal anxiety, particularly when preceding or concurrent, is a potential risk factor for EC and subsequent maternal depression.
Conclusion
Crying spells in the context of depression are complex and multifaceted. While crying is commonly associated with sadness and depression, its role as a diagnostic criterion is not straightforward. The relationship between crying and depression varies across different conditions, such as pseudobulbar affect and post-stroke pathological crying, and is influenced by factors like gender and the presence of mood disorders. Accurate diagnosis and tailored treatment are crucial for managing crying spells effectively in individuals with depression.
Sources and full results
Most relevant research papers on this topic