Destruction of black holes
Pro Research Analysisby 
Searched over 200M research papers
Destruction of Black Holes: Theoretical Possibilities and Limitations
Black Hole Destruction via Test Particles and Fields
Research has explored whether black holes can be destroyed by introducing test particles or fields with specific properties. For certain types of black holes, such as Kaluza-Klein black holes and regular (nonsingular) black holes, it is theoretically possible to destroy the event horizon and expose the central region, potentially creating a naked singularity or allowing access to quantum gravity effects. This can be achieved by sending in particles or fields with the right energy, charge, or angular momentum, especially when self-force and radiative effects are neglected in the calculations 135.
Cosmic Censorship and the Limits of Destruction
For classical black holes like the Kerr-Newman type, the weak cosmic censorship conjecture generally prevents the destruction of the event horizon. When all physical effects, such as self-force and backreaction, are properly considered, attempts to overcharge or overspin these black holes fail, and the event horizon remains intact. This holds true for both extremal and nearly extremal Kerr-Newman black holes, as shown in detailed analyses that account for second-order corrections to the black hole's mass 267.
Special Cases: Near-Extremal and Higher-Dimensional Black Holes
While extremal black holes are robust against destruction, near-extremal black holes can sometimes be pushed past their limits, resulting in the formation of naked singularities. This is possible in certain scenarios where the energy range for the test particle is very narrow, and self-force effects are neglected. In higher-dimensional charged black holes, similar results are found: extremal black holes cannot be destroyed, but near-extremal ones might be, under idealized conditions 67.
Influence of Quantum Corrections and Magnetic Fields
Quantum corrections can make black holes harder to destroy. For nonsingular, quantum-corrected rotating black holes, a quantum parameter acts as a protective factor, preventing destruction by test particles. However, destruction may still be possible through the interaction with specific scalar fields, depending on the quantum corrections involved . In the presence of strong external magnetic fields, test particles may theoretically have enough energy to destroy extremal magnetized black holes, but effective potentials prevent these particles from actually reaching the event horizon .
Destruction by Classical Fields: Scalar and Neutrino Fields
In some spacetimes, such as the Kerr–Taub–NUT spacetime, both extremal and nearly extremal black holes can be destroyed by scalar and neutrino fields if the black hole's angular momentum is sufficiently high. For scalar fields, only a narrow range of modes can destroy the horizon due to superradiance, while neutrino fields can generically destroy the horizon without being affected by backreaction effects 810.
Black Hole Evaporation and Theoretical Debates
Beyond destruction by external matter or fields, black holes are also theorized to lose mass and eventually evaporate due to Hawking radiation. While this process is widely accepted, debates continue about the exact rate and implications of black hole evaporation, especially in the absence of a complete quantum theory of gravity .
Conclusion
The destruction of black holes is a complex topic that depends on the type of black hole, the nature of the perturbing matter or field, and the inclusion of all relevant physical effects. While certain idealized or quantum-corrected black holes may be theoretically destroyed under specific conditions, classical black holes like the Kerr-Newman type are generally protected by the laws of physics, particularly when all effects are considered. The study of black hole destruction not only tests the limits of general relativity and cosmic censorship but also offers potential insights into quantum gravity and the fundamental nature of spacetime.
Sources and full results
Most relevant research papers on this topic