Dietary protein sources for weight gain
Pro Research Analysisby 
Searched over 200M research papers
Animal vs. Plant Protein Sources and Weight Gain
Research shows that the type of dietary protein—animal or plant—can influence weight gain differently. Higher intake of total protein, especially from animal sources like red and processed meat and poultry, is linked to greater long-term weight gain in adults, while plant protein does not show a clear association with weight changes Halkjær2010Hernández‐Alonso2016. In young children, dairy protein intake is most strongly associated with increased weight gain, while a diet lower in dairy protein and higher in plant protein is linked to lower weight gain .
Dairy, Whey, and Red Meat Protein Effects
Among animal proteins, dairy and milk proteins are particularly associated with weight gain in children . However, studies in rats suggest that whey protein, a dairy-derived protein, may actually reduce body weight gain and body fat compared to red meat protein, possibly due to differences in how these proteins affect metabolism and gut microbiota Belobrajdic2004Zhou2011Nychyk2021. Blended proteins (soybean-whey) and pure whey protein also promote higher body weight and better nutrient absorption compared to plant protein alone, but plant-based diets tend to support greater gut microbial diversity .
Protein Intake, Energy Balance, and Body Composition
While high-protein diets are often promoted for weight management, evidence suggests that higher total protein intake, especially when replacing carbohydrates, is associated with increased risk of weight gain and even higher risk of death in populations at high cardiovascular risk . However, in the context of energy deficit and intense exercise, higher protein intake can help preserve or even increase lean body mass while promoting fat loss, rather than overall weight gain Longland2016Hansen2021. This effect is more pronounced in individuals with certain metabolic profiles, such as prediabetes .
Plant-Based Protein Sources and Weight Gain
Plant-based protein sources, such as those from Chlorella sorokiniana (a type of algae), can support optimal weight gain and body composition in animal studies, with the best results seen at moderate protein levels (around 40% of diet) . Too much or too little protein from these sources can negatively affect growth and gut health .
Gut Microbiota and Protein Source
The impact of protein source on weight gain is also mediated by changes in gut microbiota. Animal studies show that casein (another dairy protein) can increase weight gain and negative metabolic effects, while whey protein can reduce these effects, largely through their influence on gut bacteria Nychyk2021Zhuang2024.
Conclusion
In summary, animal-based proteins—especially from red meat, poultry, and dairy—are generally associated with greater weight gain, while plant-based proteins are not clearly linked to weight increases and may even help limit weight gain. Whey protein, despite being a dairy protein, may help reduce weight gain compared to red meat and casein, possibly due to its effects on metabolism and gut microbiota. The overall impact of dietary protein on weight gain depends on the source, amount, and the individual's energy balance and metabolic health. For those seeking weight gain, animal proteins (especially dairy and meat) are most effective, but the long-term health implications should be considered. For balanced weight management, a diverse protein intake with an emphasis on plant sources may be beneficial.
Sources and full results
Most relevant research papers on this topic