Does crying help depression
Pro Research Analysisby 
Searched over 200M research papers
Does Crying Help Depression?
Crying and Depression: A Complex Relationship
The relationship between crying and depression is intricate and multifaceted. Contrary to popular belief, crying is not always a prevalent symptom in individuals with depression. Research indicates that crying is no more likely in depressed individuals compared to non-depressed individuals, and the emotional activation associated with crying is less evident in those with clinical depression . This suggests that the emotional dysregulation in depression may alter the typical crying response.
Crying as a Diagnostic Tool
Crying has been considered a potential indicator of depression, especially in clinical settings. However, studies have shown that crying alone is not a reliable diagnostic tool for depression. In a study of hospitalized patients, crying was a prominent symptom in those referred for psychiatric consultation, but it was associated with a variety of underlying conditions, including neurological disorders and major depression . This highlights the importance of a comprehensive assessment to identify the root cause of crying in patients.
Emotional Relief and Crying
The notion that crying provides emotional relief, often referred to as the catharsis hypothesis, has been widely debated. Research findings are mixed, with some studies suggesting that crying does not significantly alleviate depressive symptoms. For instance, crying was found to be no more effective in reducing depression than simply feeling like crying without shedding tears . Additionally, crying did not appear to reduce depressed affect in a non-psychiatric sample, challenging the idea that crying inherently leads to emotional relief .
Physiological Responses to Crying
Crying may have some physiological benefits, such as maintaining biological homeostasis. Studies have shown that crying can stabilize respiration rates and regulate heart rate, which may contribute to a sense of physiological balance . However, these benefits do not necessarily translate to a reduction in depressive symptoms.
Crying in Different Contexts
The context in which crying occurs can influence its effects on mood. For example, crying induced by emotional films did not facilitate the reduction of subsequent depressed mood, although it was associated with a focus on the emotional content of the film . This suggests that the situational context and the individual's focus of thought play a role in the emotional outcomes of crying.
Crying and Postpartum Depression
Crying in response to infant-related stressors has been studied in the context of postpartum depression. An educational video on infant crying did not significantly reduce postpartum depression overall, but it was effective in reducing depressive symptoms among young mothers under 25 years old . This indicates that targeted interventions addressing specific stressors related to crying can be beneficial for certain populations.
Conclusion
In summary, the relationship between crying and depression is complex and not fully understood. While crying may offer some physiological benefits, it does not consistently alleviate depressive symptoms. The effectiveness of crying as a coping mechanism may depend on individual differences, the context of the crying episode, and the underlying causes of depression. More systematic and well-designed studies are needed to clarify the role of crying in emotional regulation and its potential therapeutic benefits for depression.
Sources and full results
Most relevant research papers on this topic