Does every black hole contain a singularity
Pro Research Analysisby 
Searched over 200M research papers
Do All Black Holes Contain a Singularity?
Introduction to Black Hole Singularities
A black hole singularity is a point where gravitational forces compress matter to infinite density, and the laws of physics as we know them cease to function. The concept of singularities is deeply rooted in the theory of general relativity, which predicts that singularities form at the center of black holes. However, the nature and existence of these singularities are subjects of ongoing research and debate.
Singularities in Classical General Relativity
In classical general relativity, singularities are considered inevitable under certain conditions. The Hawking-Penrose singularity theorems suggest that singularities must form in black holes under very plausible conditions, such as the presence of a closed trapped surface7. These singularities are typically spacelike, meaning they exist at a single point in space at a given time, and are often considered the "end" of spacetime8.
Types of Singularities in Black Holes
Research indicates that different types of singularities can exist within black holes. For instance, in rotating black holes, three types of singularities have been proposed: the Belinskii-Khalatnikov-Lifshitz singularity, the Poisson-Israel mass-inflation singularity, and the Marolf-Ori singularity7. These singularities can coexist and have different physical and geometrical properties.
Quantum Gravity and Singularities
While classical general relativity predicts singularities, it is widely believed that a complete theory of quantum gravity would resolve these singularities. Quantum gravity effects are expected to modify the structure of black holes, potentially eliminating singularities altogether3. This perspective suggests that singularities are artifacts of our current incomplete understanding of gravity.
Alternative Theories and Non-Singular Black Holes
Several alternative theories propose mechanisms to avoid singularities. For example, some models suggest that gravitational self-energy could prevent the formation of singularities, resulting in a uniform energy density within the black hole instead9. Other theories propose that black holes could lead to chronology violations rather than singularities, where the collapse results in a non-singular, chronology-violating spacetime5.
Numerical and Phenomenological Studies
Numerical studies of black hole singularities, particularly in charged spherical collapse scenarios, support the mass-inflation scenario, where a null singularity precedes a central spacelike singularity10. These studies provide detailed insights into the geometry and evolution of singularities within black holes.
Conclusion
The question of whether every black hole contains a singularity is complex and depends on the theoretical framework used. In classical general relativity, singularities are considered inevitable. However, alternative theories and quantum gravity suggest that singularities might be resolved or avoided. Ongoing research continues to explore these possibilities, aiming to deepen our understanding of the true nature of black holes and singularities.
Sources and full results
Most relevant research papers on this topic
Singularities in Reissner–Nordström black holes
Black holes produced by collapse of a spherically symmetric charged scalar field in asymptically flat space must contain a null singularity on the Cauchy horizon and a central spacelike singularity.
Black-hole singularities: a new critical phenomenon.
Black-hole singularities can block the tunnel, preventing hyperspace travel, for exponents greater than the critical one.
Phenomenological aspects of black holes beyond general relativity
This paper classifies possible alternatives to classical black holes and provides a minimal set of phenomenological parameters to study their phenomenology, largely model-independent and considering relevant physics.
Highly CitedCosmological singularity theorems and black holes
This paper extends Penrose's singularity theorem to spacetimes with black holes, proving that the spacetime region outside or on horizons must contain singularities, and demonstrates its use in determining the location of singularities in cosmological scenarios.
Black holes without singularities
Gravitational collapse scenarios may lead to chronology violation, not singularities, in black holes, with closed trapped surfaces requiring weak cosmic censorship.
A note on singular and non-singular black holes
A reconstruction method can reconstruct non-singular black holes in general relativity, allowing for a singular contribution to the black hole solution.
Cauchy-horizon singularity inside perturbed Kerr black holes
Perturbative analysis and nonlinear simulations agree on the general features of the mass-inflation singularity inside rotating black holes.
Singularities and Black Holes
Understanding spacetime singularities and black holes is crucial for understanding the nature of space and time in the universe, as they connect various fundamental theories and raise questions about thermodynamics, thermodynamic laws, and quantum gravity.
Black hole singularities: A numerical approach.
The mass-inflation scenario is valid for black hole singularities, with a crushing zero-radius singularity deep inside the black hole core, suggesting a spacelike central singularity.
Highly Cited