Elemental iron vs ferrous sulfate
Pro Research Analysisby 
Searched over 200M research papers
Consensus Meter
Elemental Iron vs. Ferrous Sulfate: A Comparative Analysis
Introduction to Iron Supplementation
Iron deficiency anemia (IDA) is a prevalent condition worldwide, affecting various populations including pregnant women, children, and individuals with specific medical conditions. Two common forms of iron supplements are elemental iron and ferrous sulfate. This article synthesizes research findings comparing the efficacy, tolerability, and outcomes of these two iron supplements.
Efficacy of Ferrous Sulfate in Treating Iron Deficiency Anemia
Ferrous Sulfate in Children and Infants
Ferrous sulfate has been shown to be highly effective in increasing hemoglobin levels in children with nutritional IDA. A study comparing ferrous sulfate to iron polysaccharide complex found that ferrous sulfate resulted in a greater increase in hemoglobin concentration over 12 weeks, with a higher proportion of complete resolution of IDA. Another study in children demonstrated that ferrous sulfate led to higher hemoglobin levels and fewer residual complaints compared to iron polymaltose complex.
Ferrous Sulfate in Pregnant Women
In pregnant women, ferrous sulfate has been compared to other iron supplements such as ferrous bisglycinate. Research indicates that ferrous bisglycinate at a lower dose (25 mg/day) is as effective as ferrous sulfate (50 mg/day) in preventing ID and IDA during pregnancy, with fewer gastrointestinal complaints reported in the bisglycinate group. Additionally, intravenous iron sucrose complex has been found to be more effective than oral ferrous sulfate in achieving higher hemoglobin levels in a shorter period, with fewer side effects.
Elemental Iron: Forms and Efficacy
Elemental Iron in Fortified Foods
Elemental iron powders, such as electrolytic iron and hydrogen-reduced iron, are commonly used to fortify foods. A study comparing these forms to ferrous sulfate in wheat-based snacks found that all three significantly improved iron status in women with low iron stores. However, ferrous sulfate was more effective in increasing body iron stores compared to the other forms of elemental iron.
Elemental Iron in Clinical Settings
In patients with specific medical conditions, such as those who have undergone gastrectomy, ferrous sulfate has shown better results in improving hematologic parameters compared to ferrous glycinate chelate. The latter, despite being more bioavailable, did not perform as well in increasing ferritin levels and resolving anemia.
Tolerability and Side Effects
Gastrointestinal Side Effects
One of the main concerns with iron supplementation is gastrointestinal side effects. Studies have shown that ferrous sulfate is associated with higher incidences of gastrointestinal complaints compared to other forms of iron, such as ferrous bisglycinate and wax-matrix iron preparations . The wax-matrix preparation of ferrous sulfate, designed to reduce side effects, was better tolerated than conventional ferrous sulfate tablets.
Bioavailability and Absorption
The bioavailability of iron supplements is crucial for their efficacy. Ferrous bisglycinate has been noted to have higher bioavailability compared to ferrous sulfate, which may contribute to its effectiveness at lower doses and reduced side effects. However, in clinical trials, ferrous sulfate remains the preferred form due to its proven efficacy in increasing hemoglobin and ferritin levels.
Conclusion
Both ferrous sulfate and elemental iron supplements are effective in treating iron deficiency anemia, with ferrous sulfate often showing superior efficacy in increasing hemoglobin and ferritin levels. However, ferrous bisglycinate and other forms of elemental iron may offer advantages in terms of tolerability and bioavailability. The choice of iron supplement should consider the specific needs of the patient, potential side effects, and the clinical context. Further research is needed to optimize iron supplementation strategies for different populations.
Sources and full results
Most relevant research papers on this topic