Examples of evolutionary reversal
Pro Research Analysisby 
Searched over 200M research papers
Evolutionary Reversal: Definition and Types
Evolutionary reversal refers to the phenomenon where a trait that was lost during evolution reappears in a lineage. This can occur at different scales, from small-scale reversals (microevolutionary) such as the re-expression of a lost feature in individuals or populations, to large-scale (macroevolutionary) reversals where entire lineages regain complex traits previously lost over long evolutionary timescales 13.
Examples of Evolutionary Reversal in Animals
Limb and Digit Reappearance
Cases have been documented where animals such as horses, guinea pigs, canids, and cetaceans have re-expressed digits or limb elements millions of generations after their loss. These are considered examples of atavisms, where suppressed regulatory genes are reactivated, leading to the reappearance of ancestral traits .
Wing Evolution in Stick and Leaf Insects (Phasmids)
A well-studied example is the evolution of wings in phasmids (stick and leaf insects). Research shows that wings, once lost in certain lineages, have re-evolved multiple times. This demonstrates that even complex traits like wings can be regained, challenging the idea that such losses are always irreversible .
Reversal of Reproductive Modes
In some reptiles and fish, there is evidence for reversals in reproductive modes. For example, the lizard Zootoca vivipara shows a potential reversal from live-bearing (viviparity) back to egg-laying (oviparity). Similarly, certain fish have reacquired placental traits. These reversals are sometimes explained by hybridization (reticulation) with lineages that still possess the ancestral trait, rather than by stepwise evolutionary changes .
Multicellularity and Unicellularity in Yeast
Experimental evolution studies in yeast (Saccharomyces cerevisiae) have shown that multicellularity can evolve rapidly under selection, and when selection is reversed, unicellularity can re-evolve. This demonstrates that even major organizational changes can be reversed under the right selective pressures, although the genetic pathways involved in the reversal may differ from those in the original evolution 47.
Sex Role Reversal in Animals
In some bird species, such as coucals, and in other animals, the typical sex roles are reversed: females compete for mates and males provide parental care. This reversal of sex roles and mating systems is influenced by ecological and evolutionary factors, such as adult sex ratios and parental investment, and represents a behavioral evolutionary reversal .
Mechanisms and Implications of Evolutionary Reversal
Genetic and Developmental Mechanisms
Reversals can occur through the reactivation of suppressed genes or through hybridization with lineages that retain the ancestral trait. However, not all apparent reversals are true evolutionary reversals; some may result from developmental anomalies or gene knockouts that mimic ancestral conditions without true evolutionary reversion 128.
Ecological and Evolutionary Dynamics
Evolutionary reversals can be driven by changes in ecological conditions, competition, or selection pressures. In some cases, reversals can lead to cycling between different population states or even trigger catastrophic shifts, such as predator-prey role reversals leading to predator extinction 59.
Conclusion
Evolutionary reversal is a real and documented phenomenon, with examples ranging from the reappearance of lost limbs and wings to changes in reproductive modes, multicellularity, and behavioral roles. These reversals can occur through genetic reactivation, hybridization, or changes in selection pressures, and they challenge the traditional view that evolution is strictly irreversible, especially for complex traits 1234710.
Sources and full results
Most relevant research papers on this topic