Extraterrestrial civilizations in other galaxies
Pro Research Analysisby 
Searched over 200M research papers
Types and Energy Scales of Extraterrestrial Civilizations in Other Galaxies
Extraterrestrial civilizations are often classified by their energy usage, following the Kardashev scale. Type I civilizations use energy at the scale of their home planet, Type II harness the energy of their entire star system, and Type III civilizations can use the energy of an entire galaxy. Type III civilizations, in particular, would be of interest when searching for advanced life in other galaxies, as their energy output could be detectable across vast distances Angelo1991Mieli2023.
Search Strategies: Communication and Artifact Detection
There are two main approaches to searching for extraterrestrial civilizations: communication SETI (searching for signals) and Dysonian SETI (searching for artifacts or energy signatures). Dysonian SETI focuses on detecting the waste heat or other byproducts of large-scale energy use, such as those expected from Type III civilizations. These methods are complementary, and using both increases the chances of detection .
Infrared and Optical Searches for Galaxy-Spanning Civilizations
Recent searches have used wide-field infrared surveys, like those from the WISE and Spitzer telescopes, to look for the waste heat that would be produced by civilizations with massive energy supplies. These searches have found that galaxy-spanning (Type III) civilizations are very rare in the local universe, as no clear evidence of such civilizations has been detected so far Wright2014Wright2014. Optical searches, such as the Local Galactic Transient Survey, are also being used to look for directed energy signals (like powerful lasers) from nearby galaxies, and current technology is capable of detecting signals from civilizations using technology less advanced than what humans could build in the near future .
The Fermi Paradox and the Rarity of Advanced Civilizations
The Fermi Paradox asks why, given the vast number of stars and galaxies, we have not yet detected evidence of extraterrestrial civilizations. Some researchers argue that if advanced civilizations existed and were expansionist, they would have colonized the galaxy or left detectable traces. The lack of such evidence suggests that either advanced civilizations are extremely rare, do not expand aggressively, or choose not to communicate in ways we can detect Wright2014Kuiper1977Webb2002. Others point out that cultural factors or resource limitations could prevent widespread colonization, so the absence of evidence does not necessarily mean extraterrestrial civilizations do not exist .
Statistical Estimates and the Likelihood of Civilizations
Mathematical models, such as advanced versions of the Drake equation, have been used to estimate the number of advanced civilizations in the galaxy. Some studies suggest that there could be a small number of static civilizations (like Earth) and a larger number of potentially dynamic civilizations capable of moving around the galaxy, though these are still rare compared to the total number of stars .
Challenges in Detecting Civilizations in Other Galaxies
Detecting civilizations in other galaxies is even more challenging than within our own. The vast distances mean that only the most energy-intensive activities, such as those of Type III civilizations, would be detectable. Even then, distinguishing artificial signals from natural sources (like dust or natural infrared emissions) is difficult, and current searches have not found definitive evidence Wright2014Sagan1973Thomas2025.
Conclusion
While the vastness of the universe suggests that extraterrestrial civilizations could exist in other galaxies, current searches—using both communication and artifact detection methods—have not found clear evidence of galaxy-spanning civilizations. The rarity of detectable signatures, combined with the challenges of distinguishing them from natural phenomena, means that if such civilizations exist, they are either extremely rare, not using detectable technologies, or not interested in making contact. The search continues, with ongoing improvements in both observational technology and search strategies Wright2014Wright2014Thomas2025+1 MORE.
Sources and full results
Most relevant research papers on this topic
THE Ĝ INFRARED SEARCH FOR EXTRATERRESTRIAL CIVILIZATIONS WITH LARGE ENERGY SUPPLIES. I. BACKGROUND AND JUSTIFICATION
The infrared search for extraterrestrial civilizations with large energy supplies may be fruitful, as life has the potential for exponential growth and intelligence implies the ability to overcome limitations.
Astrobiology: resolution of the statistical Drake equation by Maccone's lognormal method in 50 steps
The Maccone's lognormal method effectively resolves the Drake equation, estimating the number of advanced civilizations in the galaxy at 2000, with static and dynamic types present.
If the Universe Is Teeming with Aliens ... WHERE IS EVERYBODY?: Fifty Solutions to the Fermi Paradox and the Problem of Extraterrestrial Life
This book explores 75 solutions to Fermi's paradox, addressing the question of why there is no evidence of extraterrestrial life despite the universe being teeming with life.
DOI