Gaviscon compared to tums for acid reflux
Pro Research Analysisby 
Searched over 200M research papers
Acid Reflux Relief: Gaviscon vs. Tums – Mechanisms and Effectiveness
How Gaviscon and Tums Work for Acid Reflux
Gaviscon and Tums are both used to relieve acid reflux, but they work in different ways. Tums is a traditional antacid (calcium carbonate) that neutralizes stomach acid quickly, raising the pH in the stomach to provide fast relief from heartburn and indigestion. Gaviscon, on the other hand, contains alginate and antacid components. When it reacts with stomach acid, it forms a gel-like "raft" that floats on top of the stomach contents, creating a physical barrier that helps prevent acid from refluxing into the esophagus, in addition to neutralizing acid to some extent 1910.
Speed and Duration of Symptom Relief
Tums acts rapidly to increase stomach pH and relieve symptoms, but it may raise the pH too much, which can sometimes lead to overcorrection and potential side effects if used excessively . Gaviscon also provides relief, but its effect is not as immediate as Tums. However, Gaviscon’s unique raft-forming action means it can provide longer-lasting protection against reflux, as the raft remains in the stomach for several hours and continues to act as a barrier 1910.
Effectiveness in Reducing Reflux Episodes
Clinical and laboratory studies show that Gaviscon is effective at reducing the number and duration of acid reflux episodes. It significantly decreases the time the esophagus is exposed to acid and reduces reflux symptoms more effectively than antacids alone in both adults and children 589. Gaviscon’s raft can move into the esophagus during reflux events, acting as a physical barrier to acid, which is a mechanism not provided by Tums 910.
Comparative Studies: Gaviscon vs. Tums
Direct comparisons in simulated gastric acid environments found that Tums increased the pH more quickly and to a higher level than Gaviscon, making it the most effective and efficient at immediate acid neutralization. However, Gaviscon was considered "perfect" at the start of each trial because it did not raise the pH excessively and provided a more balanced effect. Over time, Gaviscon’s impact on pH changed, while Tums’ effect remained constant. The study concluded that while Tums is faster and more potent at neutralizing acid, Gaviscon is preferable for ongoing management because it avoids excessive pH changes and offers longer-lasting protection .
Unique Benefits of Gaviscon’s Alginate Raft
Gaviscon’s alginate raft is especially beneficial after meals, when the "acid pocket" forms at the top of the stomach and is a major cause of post-meal reflux. Gaviscon’s raft can cap and displace this acid pocket, reducing reflux events in a dose-dependent manner 234. This mechanism is independent of pH change and is unique to alginate-based products like Gaviscon 4910.
Safety and Suitability
Both Gaviscon and Tums are considered safe for short-term use. Gaviscon’s non-systemic action and physical barrier make it suitable for a wide range of patients, including children and pregnant women, and it can be used alongside other acid-suppressing medications 89. Tums, while effective for quick relief, may not be ideal for long-term management due to the risk of excessive pH increase and potential side effects with prolonged use .
Conclusion
Tums provides rapid, strong acid neutralization and is best for immediate relief of heartburn. Gaviscon, while slower to act, offers longer-lasting protection by forming a physical barrier that prevents acid reflux, making it more suitable for ongoing management of acid reflux symptoms. For those seeking quick relief, Tums may be preferred, but for sustained protection and prevention of reflux episodes, Gaviscon’s unique raft-forming action offers significant advantages 158910.
Sources and full results
Most relevant research papers on this topic