History of theories about the origin of Earth
Pro Research Analysisby 
Searched over 200M research papers
Early Theories of Earth's Origin: Meteoritic and Nebular Hypotheses
Theories about the origin of Earth have evolved significantly over time. Early ideas, such as O.J. Schmidt's meteoritic theory, proposed that the Sun captured dust and meteorites from a galactic cloud, which then coalesced to form the planets, including Earth . This contrasted with the nebular hypothesis, which suggested that the Sun and planets formed together from a rotating cloud of gas and dust, with gravitational instability in a dense interstellar molecular cloud leading to the formation of the solar system .
Accretion and Planetesimal Models in Modern Theories
Modern research supports the idea that Earth formed through the accumulation of solid particles in the solar nebula. Dust particles stuck together to form pebbles, which then collapsed under gravity into planetesimals—bodies about 100 km in size. These planetesimals further accreted through collisions, eventually forming planetary embryos and, after a series of giant impacts, the Earth itself 1456. This process was not instantaneous; while Mars formed quickly, Earth’s growth was more gradual, with most of its mass accreted by the time of the Moon-forming impact, estimated to have occurred 70–120 million years after the solar system began 56.
Chemical and Isotopic Insights: Meteorites and Elemental Distribution
Studies of meteorites and solar composition have provided important constraints on Earth’s bulk composition and the processes involved in its formation 45. The condensation of elements from the solar nebula depended on temperature and pressure, with refractory metals and oxides condensing first, followed by metallic iron . Isotopic variations in meteorites indicate rapid formation and differentiation of planetesimals, while Earth’s chemical composition was shaped by condensation, melting, and volatile loss .
Theories on Earth's Early State: Heat, Atmosphere, and Core Formation
The early Earth was likely extremely hot and partially or fully molten, surrounded by a fragile atmosphere and subject to frequent, violent impacts 16. The accumulation of asteroid-sized bodies could have raised the planet’s initial temperature to 1,500–2,000 K . Theories about the core’s composition have evolved, with some suggesting the presence of light elements like sulfur to explain observed chemical deficiencies in the mantle and crust . The possibility of a hydride-rich core has also been proposed, suggesting that hydrogen played a significant role in the early Earth and may even contribute to the planet’s magnetic field .
Alternative and Controversial Theories
Some alternative theories challenge mainstream views. For example, one recent hypothesis suggests that thermonuclear synthesis reactions in the Earth's core continue to create elements today, and that Earth’s expansion began about 200 million years ago . These ideas remain controversial and are not widely accepted in the scientific community.
Interdisciplinary Approaches and Ongoing Debates
Understanding Earth’s origin requires input from many scientific fields, including astronomy, geochemistry, seismology, and cosmochemistry. Despite advances, no single theory fully satisfies all disciplines, and debates continue about details such as the exact processes of chemical fractionation and the role of volatiles and isotopes in early planetary heating 1210. Theories continue to be refined as new data and models emerge.
Conclusion
The history of theories about the origin of Earth reflects a progression from early meteoritic and nebular ideas to sophisticated accretion and planetesimal models, informed by geochemical and isotopic evidence. While consensus has grown around the accretionary model, questions remain about the details of core formation, chemical differentiation, and the role of volatiles. Ongoing research and interdisciplinary collaboration are essential for further unraveling the complex history of our planet’s formation.
Sources and full results
Most relevant research papers on this topic