How effective is the pill
Pro Research Analysisby 
Searched over 200M research papers
Effectiveness of Oral Contraceptive Pills: A Comprehensive Review
Introduction to Oral Contraceptive Pills
Oral contraceptive pills (OCPs) have been a cornerstone in family planning and reproductive health since their introduction in the 1960s. They are widely used due to their high effectiveness and additional health benefits. This article synthesizes recent research on the effectiveness of various types of OCPs, including progestogen-only pills and combined oral contraceptives.
Progestogen-Only Pills: Norgestrel 75 µg/day
Effectiveness in Non-Breastfeeding Women
A review of studies on the progestogen-only pill containing norgestrel 75 µg/day shows it to be highly effective. Data from six studies involving 3,144 non-breastfeeding women reported an overall failure rate ranging from 0 to 2.4 per hundred woman-years, resulting in an aggregate Pearl Index of 2.2 . This indicates a high level of contraceptive reliability under typical use conditions.
Effectiveness in Breastfeeding Women
In breastfeeding women, seven additional studies involving 5,258 participants reported 12-month cumulative pregnancy rates ranging from zero to 3.4 . Although an aggregate Pearl Index could not be calculated due to data limitations, the effectiveness appears comparable to that in non-breastfeeding women.
Combined Oral Contraceptives: 24-Day vs. 21-Day Regimens
Comparative Effectiveness
A large U.S. cohort study compared the effectiveness of 24-day and 21-day regimens of combined oral contraceptives. The study found that the 24-day regimen, which includes drospirenone and ethinyl estradiol, had lower contraceptive failure rates (2.1% after the first year and 4.7% after the third year) compared to the 21-day regimen (3.5% after the first year and 6.7% after the third year) . The adjusted hazard ratio was 0.7, indicating a statistically significant higher effectiveness for the 24-day regimen .
Impact of Body Mass Index
The study also noted a slight increase in contraceptive failure rates with higher body mass index (BMI), suggesting that obesity may slightly reduce the effectiveness of oral contraceptives .
Factors Influencing Pill Effectiveness
User Compliance and Health Conditions
The effectiveness of OCPs can be influenced by user compliance and certain health conditions. Forgetfulness in taking the pill and gastrointestinal disturbances can lead to higher actual failure rates compared to expected rates . Additionally, certain women, such as smokers, may face increased health risks when using oral contraceptives .
Non-Contraceptive Health Benefits
Despite these challenges, OCPs offer significant non-contraceptive health benefits, including reduced risks of ovarian and endometrial cancers, and improvements in conditions like dysmenorrhea and irregular menstrual bleeding .
Conclusion
Oral contraceptive pills, both progestogen-only and combined regimens, are highly effective in preventing pregnancy. The progestogen-only pill containing norgestrel 75 µg/day shows high effectiveness in both breastfeeding and non-breastfeeding women. Combined oral contraceptives, particularly the 24-day regimen, offer superior effectiveness compared to the 21-day regimen. However, user compliance and individual health conditions can impact overall effectiveness. Despite these factors, the benefits of OCPs extend beyond contraception, offering significant health advantages.
Sources and full results
Most relevant research papers on this topic