How reliable is birth control
Pro Research Analysisby 
Searched over 200M research papers
Reliability of Birth Control Methods
Overview of Birth Control Reliability
The reliability of birth control methods varies significantly depending on the type of method used and how consistently and correctly it is applied. This article synthesizes findings from multiple studies to provide a comprehensive overview of the reliability of various birth control methods.
Hormonal Contraceptives: Birth Control Pills
Birth control pills, also known as oral contraceptives (OCs), are among the most effective methods for preventing pregnancy. They work by inhibiting ovulation and creating a barrier to sperm through the thickening of cervical mucus. Studies have shown that with perfect use, the failure rate of birth control pills is very low, making them a highly reliable option . However, typical use, which accounts for human error, results in a higher failure rate.
Natural Family Planning Methods
Natural family planning methods, such as the ovulation method and the symptothermal method, have been found to be effective when used correctly. These methods require careful observation of fertility signals like cervical mucus and basal body temperature. Studies indicate that these methods can be as effective as contraceptive pills and intrauterine devices (IUDs) when users are properly educated and motivated . However, the need for strict adherence to the method's guidelines can make them less reliable for some users.
Naturopathic Birth Control Methods
Naturopathic birth control methods, which include herbal and natural remedies, have been perceived as reliable by a significant portion of users. A study conducted in Ningo-Prampram, Ghana, found that a majority of respondents agreed on the reliability and sustainability of these methods . However, the scientific evidence supporting their effectiveness is less robust compared to more conventional methods.
Barrier Methods: Condoms and Diaphragms
Barrier methods such as condoms and diaphragms offer dual protection by preventing pregnancy and reducing the risk of sexually transmitted diseases (STDs). Condoms are favored by a significant percentage of both married and unmarried women. However, their failure rates can be higher compared to hormonal methods, with diaphragms having a failure rate of around 18% .
Long-term Contraceptives: IUDs and Implants
Intrauterine devices (IUDs) and implants like Norplant are long-term contraceptive methods with very low failure rates. IUDs are regaining popularity despite concerns about pelvic inflammatory disease, while Norplant has a failure rate of just 0.5% . These methods are highly reliable but may come with side effects that lead some users to discontinue their use.
Digital Fertility Awareness Methods
Digital fertility awareness-based methods, such as the Natural Cycles app, offer a modern alternative to traditional methods. These apps track menstrual cycles and predict fertile windows. A study on the Natural Cycles app found a typical use failure rate of 6.2% and a perfect use failure rate of 2.0%, making it a relatively reliable option for those who prefer non-hormonal methods .
The Safe Period and Rhythm Methods
The safe period and rhythm methods, which involve avoiding intercourse during the fertile phase of the menstrual cycle, have higher failure rates compared to other methods. A study found a total failure rate of 11.9 per 100 woman-years for the safe period method . Similarly, the rhythm method has a failure rate of around 19% .
Conclusion
The reliability of birth control methods varies widely, with hormonal contraceptives and long-term methods like IUDs and implants being among the most reliable. Natural and digital fertility awareness methods can also be effective but require strict adherence to guidelines. Barrier methods offer additional protection against STDs but have higher failure rates. Ultimately, the choice of birth control should be tailored to individual needs and circumstances, considering both effectiveness and potential side effects.
Sources and full results
Most relevant research papers on this topic