Investor sentiments and financial market returns
Pro Research Analysisby 
Searched over 200M research papers
Consensus Meter
Investor Sentiments and Financial Market Returns
Understanding Investor Sentiment
Investor sentiment refers to the overall attitude of investors towards a particular security or financial market. It is a measure of how far an asset's value deviates from its economic fundamentals, influenced by various factors such as market data, surveys, and media content. Sentiment can significantly impact stocks that are difficult to value and costly to arbitrage, including unprofitable stocks, non-dividend-paying stocks, extreme growth stocks, and distressed stocks.
Relationship Between Investor Sentiment and Stock Market Returns
Near-Term Stock Market Returns
Research indicates that investor sentiment is strongly correlated with contemporaneous market returns. However, its predictive power for near-term future stock returns is limited. This suggests that while sentiment can explain current market movements, it does not necessarily forecast future returns effectively.
Global Evidence and Market Differences
A study assessing 50 global stock markets found a negative relationship between investor sentiment and future stock returns. This pattern holds true across both developed and emerging markets, although the impact of sentiment is more immediate in emerging markets and more enduring in developed markets. The heterogeneity in the sentiment-return relationship across individual stock markets can be attributed to differences in culture, institutions, and the extent of individual investor participation.
Emerging Markets
In emerging equity markets, investor sentiment significantly affects contemporaneous market returns and remains persistent in the short term. However, its influence diminishes over time, indicating that while sentiment is crucial for short-term investment decisions, its long-term impact is less pronounced.
U.S. and European Markets
In the U.S., investor sentiment indices have shown economic and statistical predictability power on stock market returns. Conversely, the European market exhibits weaker results in this regard. There is also evidence of a spillover effect, where U.S. investor sentiment can predict European stock market returns, and vice versa.
Investor Sentiment and Market Volatility
Investor sentiment is linked to financial market volatility, influencing phenomena such as high volatility, bubble and crash formation, and the relationships among asset prices and expected returns. By incorporating psychological research into traditional asset-pricing models, it becomes evident that variations in investor sentiment can explain these market anomalies.
Institutional vs. Individual Investor Sentiment
Institutional investor sentiment appears to have a more informed and stabilizing effect on stock prices, aligning them closer to their intrinsic values. This is because institutional sentiment often includes expectations about future cash flows, which are factored into future price expectations. On the other hand, individual investor sentiment, while influential, is often seen as a behavioral phenomenon with less impact on market efficiency and price discovery.
Predictive Measures of Investor Sentiment
Several measures of individual investor sentiment, such as fund discounts, odd-lot sales ratios, and net mutual fund redemptions, have been studied for their predictive power. While fund discounts and net redemptions can predict the size premium (the difference between small and large firm returns), the odd-lot ratio shows little evidence of predicting returns.
International Evidence
Internationally, consumer confidence as a proxy for individual investor sentiment negatively forecasts aggregate stock market returns. High sentiment levels are associated with lower future returns and vice versa. This relationship is consistent across various stock types and forecasting horizons. The impact of sentiment is more pronounced in countries with less market integrity and those culturally prone to herd-like behavior and overreaction.
Industry-Level Impact
Investor sentiment also affects industry performance, predicting short-term mispricing at the industry level. However, long-term reversals are weaker, and there is limited evidence of cross-sectional industry differences. This suggests that investor sentiment has a market-wide effect, challenging the effectiveness of industry timing strategies based on sentiment.
Conclusion
Investor sentiment plays a crucial role in financial markets, influencing both current and future stock returns, market volatility, and industry performance. While its impact varies across different markets and investor types, understanding and measuring sentiment can provide valuable insights for investment decisions. However, the predictive power of sentiment, especially for near-term returns, remains limited, highlighting the complexity of financial market dynamics.
Sources and full results
Most relevant research papers on this topic