Is crying over little things a sign of depression
Pro Research Analysisby 
Searched over 200M research papers
Crying Over Little Things: A Sign of Depression?
Introduction to Crying and Depression
Crying is a natural emotional response to various stimuli, often associated with feelings of sadness or frustration. However, when crying becomes frequent and occurs over seemingly minor issues, it may raise concerns about underlying mental health conditions, such as depression.
Crying as a Symptom of Depression
Historical and Clinical Perspectives
Historically, crying has been considered a common symptom of depression. Despite this, major psychiatric textbooks and literature reviews often do not list crying as a definitive symptom of depression 1. This omission suggests that while crying is associated with sadness, its role in diagnosing depression is not straightforward.
Empirical Evidence on Crying and Depression
Empirical studies have provided mixed results regarding the relationship between crying and depression. One study found that depressed individuals did not cry more frequently than non-depressed individuals when exposed to a standardized cry-evoking stimulus 2. This finding challenges the common belief that depression is always associated with increased crying.
Gender Differences in Crying and Depression
Crying is also influenced by gender, with women generally crying more than men. This gender difference complicates the use of crying as a diagnostic criterion for depression. Some researchers argue that including crying in depression assessments may introduce gender bias, as men may exhibit other symptoms like aggression and irritability more frequently than women 3.
Crying and Emotional Dysregulation in Depression
Emotional Activation and Crying
In individuals with depression, crying may not lead to the same emotional activation as it does in non-depressed individuals. For example, non-depressed individuals who cried showed increased sadness and physiological responses, whereas depressed individuals did not exhibit significant emotional changes after crying 2. This suggests that depression may alter the emotional functions of crying.
Crying Proneness and Mood Disorders
Patients with mood disorders, including depression, report increased crying in response to negative stimuli but do not experience the same mood improvement after crying as non-depressed individuals 5. This indicates that while crying is more frequent in depressed individuals, it may not serve its typical emotional regulation function.
Longitudinal and Preventive Insights
Early Infant Crying and Maternal Responses
Longitudinal studies have explored the impact of maternal responses to infant crying on the child's future mental health. One study found that infants whose mothers did not respond promptly to their crying were more likely to develop depression by age 18 6. This highlights the potential long-term effects of early emotional experiences on mental health.
Preventive Programs for Postnatal Depression
Preventive programs aimed at educating parents about infant crying and sleep patterns have shown promise in reducing postnatal depression symptoms. These programs help parents manage their infants' crying and sleep issues, which in turn reduces the risk of depression in caregivers 4.
Conclusion
While crying over little things can be a sign of depression, it is not a definitive indicator. The relationship between crying and depression is complex, influenced by factors such as gender, emotional regulation, and early life experiences. Understanding these nuances is crucial for accurate diagnosis and effective intervention.
Sources and full results
Most relevant research papers on this topic
Crying in Depression
Crying is not included as a symptom of depression in major textbooks, despite its common association with sadness.
Crying threshold and intensity in major depressive disorder.
Crying is not more likely in depressed individuals, and crying-related emotional activation is less evident in depressed individuals, suggesting emotions are dysregulated in this disorder.
Non-RCT
Highly CitedCrying as a Gendered Indicator of Depression
Crying should be removed from depression diagnostic criteria due to its gendered status, as it may introduce a gender bias in assessment.
Preventing Early Infant Sleep and Crying Problems and Postnatal Depression: A Randomized Trial
An education program reduces postnatal depression symptoms and sleep and cry problems in infants who are frequent feeders, with potential benefits for frequent feeders.
RCT
Large Human TrialHighly CitedDo mood disorders alter crying? a pilot investigation
Mood disorders increase the frequency of negative emotional crying and may alter the functions of this behavior, with male patients experiencing greater impact than female patients.
Observational StudyThe association between maternal-reported responses to infant crying at 4 weeks and 6 months and offspring depression at 18: a longitudinal study
Maternal responses to infant crying at 4 weeks are associated with a higher risk of developing depression in the child at 18 years.
Observational Study
Rigorous JournalMaternal anxiety versus depressive disorders: specific relations to infants' crying, feeding and sleeping problems.
Maternal anxiety disorders are associated with excessive infant crying, feeding problems, and sleeping problems, while maternal depressive disorders may contribute to infant sleeping problems due to unsettled maternal sleep or lack of daily structure.
Observational StudyHighly CitedPreventing postpartum depression using an educational video on infant crying
Watching an educational video on infant crying within 1 week of delivery did not significantly reduce postpartum depression, but was effective for young mothers aged 25 years.
RCTLarge Human TrialHow do primary care physicians respond when patients cry during routine ambulatory visits?
Physicians generally express empathy when patients cry during routine visits, but may need to consider crying as a sign of distress and systematically assess mental health status and overall functioning.
Observational StudyResponse to Infant Cry in Clinically Depressed and Non-Depressed Mothers
Clinical depression affects maternal responsiveness during infant cries, leading to less caregiving and less attuned actions compared to non-depressed mothers.
Observational StudyRigorous Journal