Major depressive disorder diagnostic criteria
Pro Research Analysisby 
Searched over 200M research papers
Major Depressive Disorder Diagnostic Criteria: Core Symptoms and Polythetic Structure
Major depressive disorder (MDD) is diagnosed using a set of criteria that require the presence of a minimum number of symptoms from a defined list. The core symptoms include persistent depressed mood (now expanded to include hopelessness in DSM-5), loss of interest or pleasure, significant changes in weight or appetite, sleep disturbances, psychomotor changes, fatigue, feelings of worthlessness or guilt, difficulty concentrating, and recurrent thoughts of death or suicide. To meet the diagnostic threshold, an individual must experience at least five of these symptoms during the same two-week period, with at least one being either depressed mood or loss of interest/pleasure 34.
Diagnostic Heterogeneity and Symptom Combinations in MDD
The polythetic nature of the criteria means that there are many different ways to meet the diagnosis. Research has shown that there are 227 possible symptom combinations that fulfill the criteria for MDD, though not all combinations are seen in clinical practice. In large patient samples, between 119 and 170 different combinations have been observed, with a small number of combinations accounting for a large proportion of cases. For example, the combination of all nine symptoms is the most common, but only a handful of combinations are present in more than 2-3% of patients. This results in significant diagnostic heterogeneity, as patients with the same diagnosis may have very different symptom profiles 1457.
Changes in DSM-5 and Clinical Implications
The transition from DSM-IV to DSM-5 brought several changes to the diagnostic criteria for MDD. The bereavement exclusion was removed, meaning that depressive symptoms following a significant loss can now be diagnosed as MDD if they meet the criteria, relying more on clinical judgment. The addition of specifiers such as "with anxious distress" and "with mixed features" allows for further characterization of symptom patterns. The new category of persistent depressive disorder (PDD) combines chronic depression and dysthymia, but its relationship to MDD remains somewhat ambiguous 34.
Criticisms and Limitations of Current Diagnostic Criteria
A major criticism of the current criteria is that they capture a broad and heterogeneous group of depressive conditions, ranging from mild, single-episode sadness to severe, chronic, and recurrent depression. This heterogeneity makes it difficult to predict prognosis or treatment response based solely on the diagnosis. The criteria do not always distinguish between those who are "truly ill" and those experiencing normal sadness or mild symptoms, and the reliability of diagnosis between clinicians has been questioned 26. The operational and polythetic approach, while increasing inclusivity, may reduce the specificity and clinical utility of the diagnosis 45.
Screening Tools and Diagnostic Performance
Screening tools like the Patient Health Questionnaire (PHQ-9) are widely used to identify individuals who may meet criteria for MDD. The PHQ-9, using a cutoff score of 10, has acceptable sensitivity and specificity for detecting MDD in various clinical settings, making it a useful tool for case finding, though it is not a substitute for a full diagnostic assessment .
Conclusion
The diagnostic criteria for major depressive disorder are based on a polythetic list of symptoms, resulting in significant heterogeneity in how the disorder presents. While the criteria are widely used in clinical and research settings, they have limitations in terms of reliability, specificity, and ability to guide prognosis or treatment. Ongoing debate and research continue to explore ways to refine the criteria to better capture the complexity and diversity of depressive disorders 1234567.
Sources and full results
Most relevant research papers on this topic